Electrocorticograms of Hippocampal and Dorsal Cortex of Two Reptiles: Comparison with Possible Mammalian Homologs

Abstract

To compare the ongoing electrical activity in possibly homologous structures of reptiles and mammals, the electrographic activity (micro-EEG) from major parts of the cortex of unanesthetized turtles (Pseudemys) and geckos (Gekko) was recorded with and without acute and chronic stimuli, physostigmine and atropine. Electrodes were placed in the medial cortex (MC) and in the dorsal cortex (DC), the possible homologs of the mammalian hippocampus and transitional or/and isocortex, respectively. The resting corticograms (1–50 Hz) are different in the two cortical areas. Both are wide-band; power falls steadily with frequency above a single maximum about 2 Hz. The MC has a nonrhythmic, low-voltage activity with occasional superimposed large sharp waves (LSWs), generally biphasic, 100–300 µV and lasting 0.25–0.75 s. The DC has smaller amplitudes (ca. 3–6 dB) at all frequencies and fewer LSWs. Reptilian LSWs are reminiscent of mammalian hippocampal sharp waves or spikes, a correlate of decreased arousal. The immobility-related rhythmic slow activity (theta), so characteristic of the hippocampus in a number of mammals, was not found in the cortex of either species of reptile under a variety of conditions. We cannot exclude the possibility of movement-related theta waves. Physostigmine injection does not produce theta, although it acts like an arousing stimulus, producing a disappearance of the LSWs and a substantial increase in the amplitude of the frequencies 12–24 Hz; these changes were more obvious in the DC. Atropine reversed the effects of physostigmine. Theta may represent a trait of the more highly differentiated hippocampal field of mammals. The condition represented by these reptiles, in which the EEG differs between parts of the pallium but without theta or reciprocal changes in the MC and DC, may be an earlier evolutionary stage. A distinctive reptilian EEG is not recognizable in Pseudemys and Gekko_tbut a number of differences from the EEG in familiar mammals are shared by these two neurologically quite different reptiles.

Toward operational architectonics of consciousness: basic evidence from patients with severe cerebral injuries

“…These frequency bands reach the strongest expressions in humans who are at the same time the carriers of a fullfledged consciousness of self and environment (Knyazev and Slobodskaya 2003). The theta oscillations predominate within the brain of a lower mammals (Klimesch 1999), while the reptile brain oscillates mostly in the delta range (Gaztelu et al 1991). Neither of these species could be assigned with a phenomenal consciousness.…”

Electrophysiological correlates of cortico-subcortical interaction: A cross-frequency spectral EEG analysis

“…Whereas the reptile brain is suggested to be an arousal system oscillating in the delta range (Gaztelu et al, 1991) associated with theta oscillations (Klimesch, 1999). Finally, primates are geared with a cortical mantle, which oscillates in the 8-12 Hz (alpha) and the 13-30 Hz (beta) frequency range .…”

The importance of comparative studies and ecological validity for understanding hippocampal structure and cognitive function

“…What would be the implications of those differences in understanding how synaptic enhancement carries out a particular cognitive function in HF? Another comparative strategy would be to look at birds and reptiles for the presence and properties of other H F characteristics already found in some mammalian species, for example, place cells, theta rhythm, and gating properties (e.g., Gaztelu et al, 1991). Such a comparative approach is a powerful research strategy that one can use to unravel the complex relationship between hippocampal structure and function.…”