In this manuscript, we fabricate copolymer blends of polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) and Nafion as overlayers on Zn and brass substrates to create electrodes for the CO 2 reduction reaction with enhanced selectivity. By varying the blend composition, the rates of proton transfer and polymer stabilization of reaction intermediates are modulated. C 2 H 4 was obtained with a Faradaic efficiency of 74.1% at −0.89 V vs RHE using 52 wt % PVDF in Nafion on top of a brass electrode. Synergy among Cu, Zn, Nafion, and PVDF allows for this high yield of C 2 H 4 . Additionally, Zn and brass electrodes modified with a Nafion overlayer in a mixed acetonitrile−water electrolyte, which contain a lower proton concentration than aqueous electrolytes, produce 60% CH 3 OH and 65% C 2 H 4 , respectively. These results enable us to develop a mechanistic framework that explains CO 2 reduction catalyst selectivity in terms of proton transfer rates and the stability of reaction intermediates. In particular, we demonstrate that slowing proton transfer to the electrode results in more CO−CO coupling and that brass stabilizes a *C 2 O 2 − intermediate to generate C 2 H 4 . As a whole, these findings will aid the CO 2 reduction community in developing next-generation catalysts with improved selectivity.