“…Based on the partial conductivities, they claim that the Al 3+ ion travels on average in overall negatively charged clusters, AlF n 3−n with n > 3, towards the positively charged electrode. However, we noticed that the partial conductivity values determined by Gheribi et al 15 are not compatible with the universal golden rule 36,37 , even for the simplest case, i.e., pure NaF, which is also an alkali halide such as the pure LiF, LiCl, and LiI, investigated here without any need for assumptions. Indeed, Koishi et al 23 showed that the universal golden rule holds for molten NaCl as well.…”