Efficacy of 8- and 4-Session Mindfulness-Based Interventions in a Non-clinical Population: A Controlled Study

Abstract

Background: Many attempts have been made to abbreviate mindfulness programmes in order to make them more accessible for general and clinical populations while maintaining their therapeutic components and efficacy. The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of an 8-week mindfulness-based intervention (MBI) programme and a 4-week abbreviated version for the improvement of well-being in a non-clinical population.Method: A quasi-experimental, controlled, pilot study was conducted with pre-post and 6-month follow-up measurements and three study conditions (8- and 4-session MBI programmes and a matched no-treatment control group, with a sample of 48, 46, and 47 participants in each condition, respectively). Undergraduate students were recruited, and mindfulness, positive and negative affect, self-compassion, resilience, anxiety, and depression were assessed. Mixed-effects multi-level analyses for repeated measures were performed.Results: The intervention groups showed significant improvements compared to controls in mindfulness and positive affect at the 2- and 6-month follow-ups, with no differences between 8- vs. 4-session programmes. The only difference between the abbreviated MBI vs. the standard MBI was found in self-kindness at 6 months, favoring the standard MBI. There were marginal differences in anxiety between the controls vs. the abbreviated MBI, but there were differences between the controls vs. the standard MBI at 2- and 6-months, with higher levels in the controls. There were no differences in depression between the controls vs. the abbreviated MBI, but differences were found between the controls vs. the standard MBI at 2- and 6-months, favoring the standard MBI. There were no differences with regard to negative affect and resilience.Conclusion: To our knowledge, this is the first study to directly investigate the efficacy of a standard 8-week MBI and a 4-week abbreviated protocol in the same population. Based on our findings, both programmes performed better than controls, with similar effect size (ES). The efficacy of abbreviated mindfulness programmes may be similar to that of a standard MBI programme, making them potentially more accessible for a larger number of populations. Nevertheless, further studies with more powerful designs to compare the non-inferiority of the abbreviated protocol and addressing clinical populations are warranted.Clinical Trials.gov Registration ID: NCT02643927

Immune dysregulation among students exposed to exam stress and its mitigation by mindfulness training: findings from an exploratory randomised trial

“…Participants randomised to the intervention attended a median of seven sessions (inter-quartile range 2-7) including one person who attended no sessions at all, and six students who attended all the sessions. Eighteen participants (67% of those randomised to the intervention) attended at least half of the mindfulness course sessions, our pre-specified "minimum dose" 42 also used in previous studies 43 , and shown to produce meaningful change 44 . Three participants provided reasons for abandoning their mindfulness course; these were schedule conflicts or being too busy.…”

Brief mindfulness, mental health, and cognitive processes: A randomized controlled trial

“…Such reduction to four sessions has also been conducted in some studies that have suggested using mindfulness for preventive purposes (Manotas, Segura, Eraso, Oggins, & McGovern, ; Nitzan‐Assayag et al, ; Pigeon, Allen, Possemato, Bergen‐Cico, & Treatman, ; Possemato et al, ). In this sense, Demarzo et al () did not find significant differences between a standard program of intervention in mindfulness of 8 weeks versus a shortened protocol of 4 weeks, reporting a similar efficacy in its positive effects. Based on these resources, a brief program of basic skills training in mindfulness was designed.…”

Mindfulness and aging

“…However, similar results were found using objective electronic measurement in a sixweek MBCT-based program that showed that adherence to practice (length, frequency, and type of meditation chosen) did not relate to outcomes 73 . Recently, a first study to directly compare an 8-week with a 4-week MBI showed improvements compared to controls in mindfulness and positive affect, but not between the 4-week and 8-week MBI 74 . Thus, abbreviated MBI might be similar to a standard MBI.…”