extinction, examining the total number of PP trials (acquisition and extinction) permits a more comprehensive picture of CR strength and also reveals the amount of time a subject continues to respond beyond the peak CR. An examination of the groups that received 2 and 16 PP paired trials in the Silver and Kimmel (1969) study reveals that , on the average , the 2-PP group required 43 trials to reach the extinction criterion , whereas the l6-PP group required only 23 trials beyond the peak CR to reach extinction. Schramm and Kimmel's (1970) replication produced similar results. Their 2-PP paired group continued to respond for 43 trials, compared with 22 trials for the 16-PP paired condition. While attenuation of the CR occurs during both PP acquisition and extinction, one might expect extinction trials, and not acquisition trials, beyond the peak CR to enhance attenuation and result in weaker CRs. The results of the Schramm and Kimmel (1970) and Silver and Kimmel (1969) studies indicate the opposite.