Effects of the COVID-19 Pandemic on the Mental Health of Healthcare Providers: A Comparison of a Psychiatric Hospital and a General Hospital

Abstract

Background:Before the COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare providers (HCPs) were already experiencing a higher prevalence of mental health disorders compared with non-healthcare professionals. Here, we report on the psychosocial functioning and stress resilience of HCPs who worked during the COVID-19 pandemic in a large-sized psychiatric facility and a large acute care hospital, both located in central Ontario, Canada.Methods:Participants completed five validated psychometric instruments assessing depression, anxiety, and stress (The Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Scale-21, DASS-21); work-related quality of life (Work-Related Quality of Life Scale, WRQoL); resilience (Connor-Davidson Resilience Scale, CD-RISC); anxiety about the novel coronavirus (Coronavirus Anxiety Scale, CAS); and loneliness (UCLA Loneliness Scale, ULS). Participants from the psychiatric hospital (n = 94) were sampled during the easing of restrictions after the first wave in Ontario, and participants from the acute care hospital (n = 146) were sampled during the height of the second wave in Ontario.Results:Data showed that HCPs from the acute care hospital and psychiatric hospital reported similar scores on the psychometric scales. There were also no significant differences in psychometric scale scores between medical disciplines at the acute care hospital. Among all HCPs, being a nurse predicted better quality of life (p = 0.01) and greater stress resilience (p = 0.031).Conclusion:These results suggest that HCPs' psychological symptoms are similar across the hospital settings sampled. Compared to other HCPs, nurses may show a unique resiliency to the pandemic. We suggest that emergencies such as the COVID-19 pandemic have a pervasive effect on HCPs. It is important to address HCPs' mental health needs in terms of crisis management and improve resilience among all HCPs during the inter-crisis period before a new challenge arrives.

Changes and Challenges in Inpatient Mental Health Care During the First Two High Incidence Phases of the COVID-19 Pandemic in Germany – Results From the COVID Ψ Psychiatry Survey

“…In many regions, telemedicine was used as a replacement, and the respective experiences were either positive, especially in affective and anxiety disorders, or not so positive, for example, in schizophrenia ( 18 , 40 , 42 ). Another interesting aspect is that absenteeism and distress levels were comparably high among mental healthcare professionals and somatic health professionals ( 43 ) but were not so present in the public debate.…”

Effects of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Healthcare Providers: Policy Implications for Pandemic Recovery

“…The ongoing pandemic is having widespread and profound impact on HCPs practising in mental health and acute care settings. The similarity of perceptions and experiences between HCPs working at two distinct hospital settings and across different time points in the pandemic ( Anzola et al 2022 ) prompted an exploration of the data for extra-local reality constructors. Importantly, the impact of policy, policy implementation and policy evaluation emerged as strong influencers to HCP experiences.…”

The impact of COVID‐19 on the mental health workforce: A rapid review

“…Many studies examined symptoms of anxiety amongst MHWs throughout the COVID‐19 pandemic ( n = 18), with reports ranging from mild to severe (Abdelfattah 2020 ; Anzola et al . 2022 ; Bommersbach et al . 2021 ; Brillon et al .…”