According to what is often referred to as the principle of competitive exclusion, no two species can have the same niche; the less effective competitor will be extinct from an area (Gause, 1932; Grinnell, 1904; Volterra, 1928). The basis for coexistence is, thus, the niche differentiation which is often achieved through resource partitioning (e.g., the theory of limiting similarity, Abrams 1983). In the species-poor Baltic Sea, the two co-existing and morphologically similar deposit-feeding amphipods, Monoporeia affinis, a glacial relict, and Pontoporeia femorata, of marine origin, dominate in abundance the benthic communities at soft sediment bottoms. Like all deposit-feeders in this area, the spring phytoplankton bloom constitutes the largest annual food input (Cederwall 1977; Elmgren, 1978; Lehtonen & Andersin, 1998). Experimental studies have demonstrated that M. affinis and P. femorata display both habitat and resource partitioning, with P. femorata burying deeper down in the sediment (Hill & Elmgren, 1987) and feeding more on aged organic matter when M. affinis is present (Byrén, Ejdung, & Elmgren, 2006). However, when released from the competition with M. affinis, P. femorata also feeds on the fresh material (Karlson, Nascimento, Näslund, & Elmgren, 2010), indicating an asymmetrical competition between