Effects of Temporal Resolution on an Inferential Model of Animal Movement

Abstract

Recently, there has been much interest in describing the behaviour of animals by fitting various movement models to tracking data. Despite this interest, little is known about how the temporal ‘grain’ of movement trajectories affects the outputs of such models, and how behaviours classified at one timescale may differ from those classified at other scales. Here, we present a study in which random-walk state-space models were fit both to nightly geospatial lifelines of common brushtail possums (Trichosurus vulpecula) and synthetic trajectories parameterised from empirical observations. Observed trajectories recorded by GPS collars at 5-min intervals were sub-sampled at periods varying between 10 and 60 min, to approximate the effect of collecting data at lower sampling frequencies. Markov-Chain Monte-Carlo fitting techniques, using information about movement rates and turning angles between sequential fixes, were employed using a Bayesian framework to assign distinct behavioural states to individual location estimates. We found that in trajectories with higher temporal granularities behaviours could be clearly differentiated into ‘slow-area-restricted’ and ‘fast-transiting’ states, but for trajectories with longer inter-fix intervals this distinction was markedly less obvious. Specifically, turning-angle distributions varied from being highly peaked around either or at fine temporal scales, to being uniform across all angles at low sampling intervals. Our results highlight the difficulty of comparing model results amongst tracking-data sets that vary substantially in temporal grain, and demonstrate the importance of matching the observed temporal resolution of tracking devices to the timescales of behaviours of interest, otherwise inter-individual comparisons of inferred behaviours may be invalid, or important biological information may be obscured.

The link between behavioural type and natal dispersal propensity reveals a dispersal syndrome in a large herbivore

“…Three features of the trajectory were estimated: (i) the mean distance between two successive locations; (ii) the mean net square displacement between each location [40] and the barycentre of all locations; and (iii) the mean turning angle between two successive segments and its standard error, providing an index of path sinuosity, with low values corresponding to a more linear path. At the home range scale, only the first two of these metrics were calculated, as path sinuosity with inter-fix intervals of 4 or 6 h is not appropriate [41]. Furthermore, at this scale, the mean distance between two successive locations and the mean distance to the barycentre were strongly dependent on winter home range size.…”

Detection range of songbirds using a stopover site by automated radio‐telemetry

“…Attempting to detect individuals almost continuously within an array should improve the accuracy and precision of position estimates via triangulation (e.g., Ward et al. ) and improve the ability of statistical models to successfully distinguish between behavioral modes (e.g., stopover vs. active migration; Postlethwaite and Dennis ).…”

An evaluation of behavior inferences from Bayesian state‐space models: A case study with the Pacific walrus

“…In addition to observational errors, differences between/among behavior state movement metric distributions may influence state‐space model classification accuracies (Codling and Hill , Beyer et al . , Postlethwaite and Dennis , Homburger et al . ).…”

“…Although previous research has evaluated state‐space model behavior classifications, studies applicable to free‐ranging animals have been restricted to simulated data sets that did not incorporate observation error (Beyer et al . , Postlethwaite and Dennis ). Thus, an evaluation of state‐space model behavior classifications with empirical data would provide researchers, managers, and policy‐makers with novel information to improve scientific investigations and conservation policy decisions.…”