Effects of Support Dogs on Eyewitness Anxiety during Questioning

Abstract

Being an eyewitness to a crime can be a traumatic event, especially if the eyewitness is the victim. In addition, following the crime the witness is susceptible to being distressed further during questioning. The current research examined the effects a trained support dog would have on mock witnesses’ anxiety (as measured by heartrate) during questioning. Participants observed a video and answered questions from an actual uniformed police officer, similar to a normal eyewitness interview. During the interview, participants were either presented with a support dog or a glass of water (control). Results indicated that while the uniformed officer increased participants’ anxiety significantly, the support dog successfully decreased anxiety almost to the point of baseline, and significantly more than the control condition. Implications and real-world application are discussed.

Police Officers’ Best Friend?: An Exploratory Analysis of the Effect of Service Dogs on Perceived Organizational Support in Policing

“…Unlike some of the previously discussed strategies, the stress reducing effects of dogs require no conscious effort. In a quasi-experimental design study, the presence of a dog during police officer questioning of an eyewitness significantly decreased the witness’s heart rate to baseline compared to the control group that was given a glass of water (Peters, 2017). Allen et al (1991; 2002) found dogs provide stress coping physiological benefits during stressful tasks.…”

Environmental Considerations for Trauma‐Responsive Juvenile and Family Courts: A Review of the Literature with Recommendations for Practice

“…Some courts even employ court facility dogs to assist children and other vulnerable witnesses (Dellinger, ; Sandoval, ). New research has found experimental evidence that the presence of a trained support dog had a beneficial impact on witness anxiety during a mock interrogation (Peters, ), but more research is needed.…”

Facility Dogs in the Courtroom: Comfort Without Prejudice?

“…The quality of testimony that could be elicited from such witnesses due to the comfort of a facility dog may outweigh the negligible prejudice that could occur. Indeed, support dogs have been shown to reduce anxiety among eyewitnesses who are interviewed following a crime (Peters, 2017).…”