Effects of STN DBS on Rigidity in Parkinson's Disease

Abstract

We quantified the effects of deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the subthalamic nucleus (STN) and medication on Parkinsonian rigidity using an objective measure of work about the elbow joint during a complete cycle of imposed 1-Hz sinusoidal oscillations. Resting and activated rigidity were analyzed in four experimental conditions: 1) off treatment; 2) on DBS; 3) on medication; and 4) on DBS plus medication. Rigidity at the elbow joint was also assessed using the Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS). We tested ten patients who received STN DBS and ten age-matched neurologically healthy control subjects. The activated rigidity condition increased work in both Parkinson's disease (PD) patients and control subjects. In PD patients, STN DBS reduced both resting and activated rigidity as indicated by work and the UPDRS rigidity score. This is the first demonstration that STN stimulation reduces rigidity using an objective measure such as work. In contrast, the presurgery dose of antiparkinsonian medication did not significantly improve the UPDRS rigidity score and reduced work only in the activated rigidity condition. Our results suggest that STN DBS may be more effective in alleviating rigidity in the upper limb of PD patients than medications administered at presurgery dosage level.

Meta-analysis comparing deep brain stimulation of the globus pallidus and subthalamic nucleus to treat advanced Parkinson disease

“…For instance, a functional imaging study demonstrated a continuous decline of dopaminergic function in patients with advanced PD after bilateral STN stimulation. 8,15,24,40 One study included in our meta-analysis stated that medication doses were higher after GPi DBS compared with preoperative doses. 53 Our review confirms that STN DBS was more likely to reduce than to increase levels of medications for patients with PD.…”

Novel Methods to Evaluate Symptoms in Parkinson's Disease – Rigidity and Finger Tappin

“…In the present analysis, rigidity was quantified by "work", in which the average work was done by the torque motor over one cycle (Shapiro et al 2007). However, the concept of "work" views the flexion and extension movements as a single system, and strictly speaking, it is different from the sum of the differences of averaged torque values that we extracted.…”

Brain Stimulation for Seizure Control: Considerations and Potential Mechanisms

“…For example, some speculate that prolonged electrical stimulation "jams" neuronal circuits (Greenberg 2002); however, this explanation is vague from a neurophysiological point of view. Slightly more developed theories (Pollo and Villemure 2007;Shapiro, Vaillancourt et al 2007;Montgomery and Gale 2008) have proposed mechanisms involving "inhibition of synaptic transmission", a.k.a. the neurochemical hypothesis, or "depolarization blockade", a.k.a.…”