Effects of Resistance Training Prior to Total Hip or Knee Replacement on Post-operative Recovery in Functional Performance: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Abstract

ObjectiveTo evaluate the effectiveness of pre-operative resistance training in patients allocated to TJR surgery on selected post-operative outcomes, via a meta-analysis of studies using exercise modalities and loading intensities objectively known to promote gains in muscle size and strength in adults of young-to-old age.DesignA systematic review and meta-analysis.Literature SearchCochrane Central, MEDLINE, EMBASE, and PEDro were searched on August 4th 2021.Study SelectionRandomized Controlled Trials (RCTs) were included if (i) they compared pre-operative lower-limb-exercises before elective TJR with standard care, (ii) explicitly reported the exercise intensity, and (iii) reported data on functional performance.Data SynthesisThis systematic review and meta-analysis is reported in accordance with the PRISMA reporting guidelines. A random effects model with an adjustment to the confidence interval was performed for pooling the data.ResultsOne thousand studies were identified. After applying exclusion criteria, five RCTs were located including 256 participants (mean age ranged from 61 to 72 years, 54% women). Moderate-to-large improvements in functional performance and maximal knee extensor strength were observed at 3 months after surgery along with small-to-moderate effects 12 months post-operatively. For patient-reported outcomes, small-to-moderate improvements were observed at 3 months post-operatively with no-to-small improvements at 12 months.ConclusionPrehabilitation efforts involving progressive resistance training provides an effective means to improve post-operative outcomes related to functional performance, knee extensor strength and patient-reported outcome in patients undergoing TJR. Due to large methodological diversity between studies, an optimal loading intensity remains unknown.Systematic Review RegistrationProspero ID: CRD42021264796.

Effects of blood-flow restricted exercise versus conventional resistance training in musculoskeletal disorders—a systematic review and meta-analysis

“…This is also reflected by large PIs for all outcome parameters, suggesting that future studies may impact the results of the present study. However, since only RCTs were included and we applied a random effects analysis model adjusted for CI due to the low number of studies included [ 33 , 54 ], the present results may still represent a valid assessment of the follow-up scores between BFR-RT versus HL-RT in the rehabilitation of selected patient groups.…”

Arthritis Foundation/HSS Workshop on Hip Osteoarthritis, Part 3: Rehabilitation and Exercise

“…There is currently no consensus recommendation for prehabilitation, due to insufficient evidence on dosing and intensity. However, limited evidence supports exercise interventions to improve preoperative pain and postoperative function [36,56,57]. Major limitations of the current evidence include heterogeneous studies, small sample sizes, and a lack of THA-specific studies.…”

Preoperative Education and Prehabilitation in Total Hip Arthroplasty Patients: A Commentary

“…In 2022, Jørgensen et al published a systematic review with meta-analysis on the effects of preoperative resistance training [7]. The authors said that many prehab studies include programs that may not be at a sufficient load or intensity to induce changes in muscle strength.…”