Effects of online palliative care training on knowledge, attitude and satisfaction of primary care physicians

Abstract

BackgroundThe Spanish Palliative Care Strategy recommends an intermediate level of training for primary care physicians in order to provide them with knowledge and skills. Most of the training involves face-to-face courses but increasing pressures on physicians have resulted in fewer opportunities for provision of and attendance to this type of training. The effectiveness of on-line continuing medical education in terms of its impact on clinical practice has been scarcely studied. Its effect in relation to palliative care for primary care physicians is currently unknown, in terms of improvement in patient's quality of life and main caregiver's satisfaction. There is uncertainty too in terms of any potential benefits of asynchronous communication and interaction among on-line education participants, as well as of the effect of the learning process.The authors have developed an on-line educational model for palliative care which has been applied to primary care physicians in order to measure its effectiveness regarding knowledge, attitude towards palliative care, and physician's satisfaction in comparison with a control group.The effectiveness evaluation at 18 months and the impact on the quality of life of patients managed by the physicians, and the main caregiver's satisfaction will be addressed in a different paper.MethodsRandomized controlled educational trial to compared, on a first stage, the knowledge and attitude of primary care physicians regarding palliative care for advanced cancer patients, as well as satisfaction in those who followed an on-line palliative care training program with tutorship, using a Moodle Platform vs. traditional education.Results169 physicians were included, 85 in the intervention group and 84 in the control group, of which five were excluded. Finally 82 participants per group were analyzed. There were significant differences in favor of the intervention group, in terms of knowledge (mean 4.6; CI 95%: 2.8 to 6.5 (p = 0.0001), scale range 0-33), confidence in symptom management (p = 0.02) and confidence in terms of communication (p = 0.038). Useful aspects were pointed out, as well as others to be improved in future applications. The satisfaction of the intervention group was high.ConclusionsThe results of this study show that there was a significant increase of knowledge of 14%-20% and a significant increase in the perception of confidence in symptom management and communication in the intervention group in comparison with the control group that received traditional methods of education in palliative care or no educational activity at all. The overall satisfaction with the intervention was good-very good for most participants.This on-line educational model seems a useful tool for palliative care training in primary care physicians who have a high opinion about the integration of palliative care within primary care. The results of this study support the suggestion that learning effectiveness should be currently investigated comparing different Internet interventions, instead of Inte...

Virtual patients: Development in cancer nursing education

“…This finding mirrors that of Pelayo et al, (2011) who, through a randomised controlled trial with 169 primary care physicians, found those undertaking the online learning package showed a significant increase in knowledge, perceived confidence in symptom management and communication, when compared to the half of the group receiving traditional teaching methods. In addition, the benefits of developing knowledge on how to manage sensitive issues in an online learning situation were noted.…”

Evaluation of three different methods of distance learning for postgraduate diagnostic imaging education: A pilot study

“…Prominent differences in ratings between methods (i.e., .30% difference in positive rating between at least 2 of the methods) were noted by at least 1 subgroup in 8 of the survey questions (4,(7)(8)(9)(10)(11)(12)(13). While this did not trend in favor of any one method, participants ultimately indicated that they were most willing to use the PowerPoint method.…”

“…5 Recent advances in Web technologies and applications have led to an increase in the popularity of distance learning programs in health care education. Technical, logistical, and cost-related limitations still exist (particularly in international collaborations), 11,13,14 but even so, the specialty of radiology, because it is largely image based, seems well positioned to transfer a portion of its course delivery to an online format.…”

“…However, there are still gaps in our knowledge: No previously reported studies have evaluated the effectiveness of postgraduate distance learning in chiropractic radiology residencies; there is still a need to investigate learning effectiveness between different Internet-based distance education formats; 11 and no consensus has been reached on the optimum format for distance learning models within the various areas of professional residency education. 12 The primary purpose of this prospective, controlled pilot study was to evaluate the perceived effectiveness of 3 different Web-based educational delivery methods by both radiology residents (students) and chiropractic radiologists (observers) in achieving the course objective and goals.…”

“…2,3,11 These latter studies have implications for programs in remote regions of the world or where access to experts in specific specialty areas is limited.…”