A series of four experiments was performed to study the effects of colony differences in rats either with or without olfactory bulb damage. Olfactory bulb damage was found to have the opposite effect upon muricide in rats from two different colonies, with OB damage causing an increase from a low initial rate in one colony and a decrease from a high rate in the other. In addition, one experiment dealt with the possibility that the high initial rate of killing in one colony was due to deprivation during shipping. The results did not provide conclusive evidence for an artifact. The overall results were discussed in terms of generalizing from studies employing rats from different colonies, and suggestions for improving generality were made.Recently, the strain of rat used in research has been found to be an important variable (e.g., Richman, Gulkin, & Knoblock, 1972; Thorne, Aaron, & Latham, 1973;Wilcock & Broadhurst, 1967). For example, Thome et al. (I973) found differences between strains in emotionality and in the rate of mouse killing observed after olfactory bulb (OB) damage.Using the same strain and a similar methodology, Thome, Aaron, and Latham (1974), however, obtained results different from those found by Sieck (1972) and Sieck and Gordon (1973). Thorne et al. (1974) found that damage to the OB rostral to the frontal neocortex did not have an effect upon emotionality, while additional damage ventral to the frontal region resulted in emotionality increases. In contrast, Sieck and Sieck and Gordon found increases in emotionality in all lesioned groups, including those with only minor damage rostral to the frontal area . Each study used rats obtained from different colonies; Thorne et a1. (1974) obtained rats originally from Research Animals, Inc. (Braddock, Pennsylvania), while Sieck used rats from Simonsen Laboratories (Gilroy, California). Thus, the possibility arises that there may be behavioral differences between colonies of the same strain. This is not entirely unlikely since most breeding colonies are genetically isolated. In fact, in a pilot study in this laboratory, differences in the rate of mouse killing were observed between rats of the same strain from two different colonies follOWing OB lesions. Also, Karli, Vergnes, and Didiergeorges (1969) reported that after using mouse-killing rats for breeding for about 2 years, there was an increase in the incidence of mouse killing observed in rats with lesions of the olfactory bulb. The following study was an elaboration of an earlier pilot study in an attempt to demonstrate that differences in behavior exist between reproductively isolated colonies of the same strain of rat.
EXPERIMENT IThe first experiment was designed to investigate the effects of OB damage upon muricidal behavior in Long-Evans rats from different colonies. In order to assess changes in muricide, animals with OB lesions were compared with operated control (OC) subjects.
MethodSubjects. The subjects were 74 adult male Long-Evans rats; 32 were descendants of breeding stock origina...