Effects of Nursing Care Based on Watson’s Theory of Human Caring on Anxiety, Distress, And Coping, When Infertility Treatment Fails: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Abstract

Introduction: The failure of infertility treatment leads to individual, familial, and social problems. The objective of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of the nursing care program based on Watson’s "Theory of Human Caring" on anxiety and distress caused by coping when the treatment fails. Methods: This study randomized controlled trial study was conducted from April to November 2012, with 86 Turkish women with infertility (intervention group: 45, control group: 41). Follow-up of 32 infertile women, who failed infertility treatment from intervention group, and 35 infertile women, who failed infertility treatment from control group, continued for another four weeks. Data were collected through Spiel Berger’s State/Trait Anxiety Inventory, Distress Scale, and Ways of Coping Questionnaire. The analyses of data were conducted using SPSS ver 13. Results: The intervention and control groups significantly differed in terms of anxiety, distress, and coping levels. The intervention group’s mean anxiety score decreased by thirteen points and distress by fourteen points (in a positive direction). The intervention group’s mean positive coping style score increased. Whereas a negative increase was observed in the control group’s values depending on the failure of the treatment. Conclusion: Watson’s theory of human caring is recommended as a guide to nursing patients with infertility treatment to decrease levels of anxiety and distress, and to increase the positive coping style among infertile women.

<p>Women and Infertility in a Pronatalist Culture: Mental Health in the Slums of Mumbai</p>

“…Healthy coping strategies on the other hand, have been shown to help women weather the difficulties of infertility with better mental health outcomes. 26,44,45 Unlike previous studies that have found that higher education was a protective factor for infertility and related mental health distress, 3,14 educational level was not significant in the current study. This may be due to the fairly even low educational levels of our slum-dwelling participants, ranging mostly (>70%) from illiteracy, to highersecondary.…”

Psychosocial Consequences of Female Infertility in Iran: A Meta-Analysis

“…Infertility diagnosis and the subsequent treatment process usually impose excruciating stress on couples. Several studies have reported that couples with infertility are prone to experiencing depression (6), anxiety (7), sexual intercourse problems, marital problem (8,9), decrease in selfconfidence (10), and low levels of psychological well-being (11,12) and quality of life (13).…”

Cultural adaptation and psychometric validation of the Caring Efficacy scale in a sample of Italian nurses

“…Non-caring models are more task-oriented than psychological and social aspects; these models can lead to patient dissatisfaction as a main threat to quality care [7]. Watson’s theory was used in different fields of nursing [8,9]. This suggests that it is necessary to address and assess nurses’ caring experience to improve their awareness, as well as their caring outcomes [10].…”