Effects of Internet Use on Health and Depression: A Longitudinal Study

Abstract

BackgroundThe rapid expansion of the Internet has increased the ease with which the public can obtain medical information. Most research on the utility of the Internet for health purposes has evaluated the quality of the information itself or examined its impact on clinical populations. Little is known about the consequences of its use by the general population.ObjectiveIs use of the Internet by the general population for health purposes associated with a subsequent change in psychological well-being and health? Are the effects different for healthy versus ill individuals? Does the impact of using the Internet for health purposes differ from the impact of other types of Internet use?MethodsData come from a national US panel survey of 740 individuals conducted from 2000 to 2002. Across three surveys, respondents described their use of the Internet for different purposes, indicated whether they had any of 13 serious illnesses (or were taking care of someone with a serious illness), and reported their depression. In the initial and final surveys they also reported on their physical health. Lagged dependent variable regression analysis was used to predict changes in depression and general health reported on a later survey from frequency of different types of Internet use at an earlier period, holding constant prior depression and general health, respectively. Statistical interactions tested whether uses of the Internet predicted depression and general health differently for people who initially differed on their general health, chronic illness, and caregiver status.ResultsHealth-related Internet use was associated with small but reliable increases in depression (ie, increasing use of the Internet for health purposes from 3 to 5 days per week to once a day was associated with .11 standard deviations more symptoms of depression, P = .002). In contrast, using the Internet for communication with friends and family was associated with small but reliable decreases in depression (ie, increasing use of the Internet for communication with friends and family purposes from 3 to 5 days per week to once a day was associated with .07 standard deviations fewer symptoms of depression, P = .007). There were no significant effects of respondents’ initial health status (P = .234) or role as a caregiver (P = .911) on the association between health-related Internet use and depression. Neither type of use was associated with changes in general health (P = .705 for social uses and P = .494 for health uses).ConclusionsUsing the Internet for health purposes was associated with increased depression. The increase may be due to increased rumination, unnecessary alarm, or over-attention to health problems. Additionally, those with unmeasured problems or those more prone to health anxiety may self-select online health resources. In contrast, using the Internet to communicate with friends and family was associated with declines in depression. This finding is comparable to other studies showing that social support is beneficial for well-being and l...

Relationship between internet use and depression: Focus on physiological mood oscillations, social networking and online addictive behavior

“…Recent study by Kraut and associates (in methodology, Center for Epidemiologic Studies of Depression Scale was used) suggested that when internet is used for strengthening communication and interaction with family members and friends, the depression symptoms might in fact be reduced. On the other hand, other online activities, such as searching for health information, may increase depression (Bessiere, Pressman, Kiesler, & Kraut, 2010). According to our opinion, it is possible that using internet for enhancing social support (i.e.…”

The association of exposure to suicide-related Internet content and emergency department visits in children: A population-based time series analysis

“…The latter has been associated with a decline in depressive symptoms and the resulting support network has shown beneficial effects on mental well-being. 26 Only one study to date has explored the relationship between ED visits for mental health concerns and highly publicized suicides of two local teenagers in the media. Among children age 12-18 years, the authors found a significant increase in ED presentations for mental illness, substance misuse or abuse, and intentional selfharm, but no significant effect on suicidal status (ideation, plan, gesture or attempt) or psychiatric hospitalization rate.…”

Interactions between health searchers and search engines

“…Others have also examined the effect of health search on user's affective state, showing that the frequency and placement of serious illnesses in captions for symptom searches increases the likelihood of negative emotional outcomes [22]. Other research has shown that health-related Web usage has been linked with increased depression [6].…”