Effects of Forefoot Shoe on Knee and Ankle Loading during Running in Male Recreational Runners

Abstract

Objectives: Although overuse running injury risks for the ankle and knee are high, the effect of different shoe designs on Achilles tendon force (ATF) and Patellofemoral joint contact force (PTF) loading rates are unclear. Therefore, the primary objective of this study was to compare the ATF at the ankle and the PTF and Patellofemoral joint stress force (PP) at the knee using different running shoe designs (forefoot shoes vs. normal shoes). Methods: Fourteen healthy recreational male runners were recruited to run over a force plate under two shoe conditions (forefoot shoes vs. normal shoes). Sagittal plane ankle and knee kinematics and ground reaction forces were simultaneously recorded. Ankle joint mechanics (ankle joint angle, velocity, moment and power) and the ATF were calculated. Knee joint mechanics (knee joint angle velocity, moment and power) and the PTF and PP were also calculated. Results: No significant differences were observed in the PTF, ankle plantarflexion angle, ankle dorsiflexion power, peak vertical active force, contact time and PTF between the two shoe conditions. Compared to wearing normal shoes, wearing the forefoot shoes demonstrated that the ankle dorsiflexion angle, knee flexion velocity, ankle dorsiflexion moment extension, knee extension moment, knee extension power, knee flexion power and the peak patellofemoral contact stress were significantly reduced. However, the ankle dorsiflexion velocity, ankle plantarflexion velocity, ankle plantarflexion moment and Achilles tendons force increased significantly. Conclusions: These findings suggest that wearing forefoot shoes significantly decreases the patellofemoral joint stress by reducing the moment of knee extension, however the shoes increased the ankle plantarflexion moment and ATF force. The forefoot shoes effectively reduced the load on the patellofemoral joint during the stance phase of running. However, it is not recommended for new and novice runners and patients with Achilles tendon injuries to wear forefoot shoes.

Effects of different contact angles during forefoot running on the stresses of the foot bones: a finite element simulation study

“…Whilst acknowledging the existence of multiple contributing factors, it is noteworthy that the utilization of specific running shoes (namely, the Nike ZoomX Alphafly) played a significant role. Subsequently, forefoot running shoes garnered increased attention from researchers ( Lu et al, 2022 ; Quan et al, 2023 ), prompting other sports brands to engage in the development and innovation of such footwear. Hence, given the specialized nature of the running shoes designed for forefoot runners, it is plausible that this study may offer novel insights to guide their athletic pursuits.…”

Biomechanical Analysis of Latin Dancers’ Lower Limb during Normal Walking

“…M a represents the plantar flexion moment of the ankle joint, and ATF is calculated using the following formula [39]:…”

Computational Biomechanics and Machine Learning: Charting the Future of Molecular and Cellular Biomechanics Field

“…Sports biomechanics featured prominently in the 2022 volume, with studies exploring how biomechanical principles can improve athletic performance and reduce injury risk. He [4] examined leg dynamics in badminton players, while Lu et al [5] investigated the effect of different footwear on knee and ankle loading during running. Both studies highlighted the importance of individualizing equipment and training regimens for optimal performance and injury prevention.…”