Effects of electrical stimulation applied in combination with shock chilling method on selected quality attributes of beef from young bulls, heifers, and cows carcasses
Abstract:The study was aimed at determining the effect of electrical stimulation (ES) and shock method of chilling on beef pH, tenderness and losses of half‐carcass weight. It was demonstrated that the use of treatments caused a rapid acceleration of the post mortem changes rate in heifers and cows half‐carcasses meat. ES accelerated pH decline in bulls half‐carcasses as well, however did not cause the differences in the ultimate pH. The treatments allowed to obtain 90 and 70% of heifers and cows half‐carcasses, respec… Show more
“…The subsequent part of the study aimed to determine the effect of different meat production variants (chilling method slow, fast, accelerated + ES/NES) on changes in the industrial indicators (pH and temperature) of beef quality [ 32 , 38 ]. This complex approach was expected to allow identifying the optimal variant of meat production, ensure its high quality, and reduce its harmful effect on environment.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Given the results presented above, it has been concluded that the coupled use of HEVS performed using an own-construction device and a fast chilling method is justified considering both the economic and meat quality class established based on pH [ 32 ].…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…The decision to choose m . longissimus as the representative muscle for pH measurements was driven by the results our previous research [ 30 – 32 ]. Before the measurements made for meat from a given experimental group (ES, NES), the electrode was washed with distiller water and the pH-meter was calibrated.…”
Among the challenges of sustainable management of meat production, the key issue is to improve the energy efficiency of production processes, which will consequently affect the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. Such effects are achieved by combining various chilling systems with electrical stimulation that determines the quality of meat at the slaughter stage. The novelties of the research undertaken included determining the impact of various variants of meat production (chilling method: slow, fast, accelerated + HVES/NES) on changes in the basic (industrial) quality indicators (pH and temperature) of beef produced from Polish Holstein-Friesian breed cattle, and then indicating the optimal variant for energy-efficient (sustainable) beef production. The HVES and the fast chilling method yielded positive economic (meat weight loss), technological (high quality, hot-boning), energetic (lower electricity consumption), and organizational effects (reduced chilling and storage surfaces and expenditures for staff wages) compared to the slow and accelerated methods. Reaching the desired final temperature with an increased amount of chilled meat enables obtaining a few-fold decrease in the specific energy consumption and a higher energy efficiency of the process. This allows recommending the above actions to be undertaken by entrepreneurs in the pursuit of sustainable meat production.
“…The subsequent part of the study aimed to determine the effect of different meat production variants (chilling method slow, fast, accelerated + ES/NES) on changes in the industrial indicators (pH and temperature) of beef quality [ 32 , 38 ]. This complex approach was expected to allow identifying the optimal variant of meat production, ensure its high quality, and reduce its harmful effect on environment.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Given the results presented above, it has been concluded that the coupled use of HEVS performed using an own-construction device and a fast chilling method is justified considering both the economic and meat quality class established based on pH [ 32 ].…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…The decision to choose m . longissimus as the representative muscle for pH measurements was driven by the results our previous research [ 30 – 32 ]. Before the measurements made for meat from a given experimental group (ES, NES), the electrode was washed with distiller water and the pH-meter was calibrated.…”
Among the challenges of sustainable management of meat production, the key issue is to improve the energy efficiency of production processes, which will consequently affect the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. Such effects are achieved by combining various chilling systems with electrical stimulation that determines the quality of meat at the slaughter stage. The novelties of the research undertaken included determining the impact of various variants of meat production (chilling method: slow, fast, accelerated + HVES/NES) on changes in the basic (industrial) quality indicators (pH and temperature) of beef produced from Polish Holstein-Friesian breed cattle, and then indicating the optimal variant for energy-efficient (sustainable) beef production. The HVES and the fast chilling method yielded positive economic (meat weight loss), technological (high quality, hot-boning), energetic (lower electricity consumption), and organizational effects (reduced chilling and storage surfaces and expenditures for staff wages) compared to the slow and accelerated methods. Reaching the desired final temperature with an increased amount of chilled meat enables obtaining a few-fold decrease in the specific energy consumption and a higher energy efficiency of the process. This allows recommending the above actions to be undertaken by entrepreneurs in the pursuit of sustainable meat production.
“…Due to the possibility of exciting muscles through both the nervous system and muscle fiber conductivity, the HVES is considered the most effective method for meat quality improvement (Żywica, 2010). For this reason, the second part of this study aimed to determine the effect of high-voltage electrical stimulation of beef half-carcasses with an own-construction device (Żywica & Banach 2014) and their chilling with three methods: slow, accelerated, and fast two-phase, on the rate of changes in meat pH, being its main quality attribute (Contreras-Castillo et al 2016; Banach et al 2018). This complex approach was expected to allow identifying the optimal variant of meat production, ensure its high quality and reduce its harmful effect on environment.…”
Entrepreneurs implementing the concept of sustainable development of meat production are highly interested in combining various red meat chilling systems with quality-improving techniques. Therefore, we analyzed the impact of high-voltage electrical stimulation (HVES) and selected chilling methods on changes in quality characteristics and weight loss of beef. We also studied energy consumption based on the heat balance of chilling chambers during the fast chilling of varying amounts of raw material.
The HVES and the fast chilling method yielded positive economic (meat weight loss), technological (high quality, hot-boning), energetic (lower electricity consumption), and organizational effects (increased chilling speed, reducing of storage surfaces and expenditures for staff wages) compared to the slow and accelerated methods. Reaching the desired final temperature with an increased amount of chilled meat enabled a few-fold reduction in the total heat collected from the chambers and in meat weight loss. This allows recommending the above actions to be undertaken by entrepreneurs in the pursuit of sustainable meat production.
“…Most of the studies held to the principle of –1 °C by 5 hr postmortem, such as chilling beef loins at –20 °C so the temperature reached –1.5 °C within 1.5 hr (Table , F1, F2), or allowing beef loins chilled at –20 °C to reach 0 °C at 2 hr postmortem (Table , F4). Some blast chilling procedures have also been studied, where beef muscles were held at –30 to –40 °C until the core temperature reached –1 °C at 3.5 hr postmortem (Table , F13), or shock chilling, where carcass sides were chilled at –3 to –5 °C until the freezing point was reached on the surface of the carcass (Banach, Modzelewska‐Kapituła, Wichman, Tkacz, & Żywica, ; Troeger, ; Żywica, Banach, & Gornowicz, ); or cryogenic chilling, where beef carcasses were held at –70 °C for 5 hr, and then the carcasses reached –2 to 0 °C at 5 hr postmortem (Table , F20). In lamb, the very fast chilling has been evaluated, where loins were chilled at –15 °C and the temperature of the muscle reached –1.9 to 0.7 °C (Table , F22 to F25); and ultra‐rapid chilling in which suckling lamb carcasses were chilled at –20 °C for 3.5 hr, and the temperature at 5 hr was –0.1 °C (Table , F31 to F32).…”
Section: Overview Of the Chilling Methods Applied To Red Meatmentioning
Chilling procedures have been widely used in livestock abattoirs since the development of refrigeration systems. The major criteria when applying chilling regimes is not only complying with regulations, but economic concerns, and also meat safety and quality assurance requirements. Given recent developments, an updated review is required to guide the industry to choose the best chilling method and to inspire the development of new approaches to chilling. Thus in this paper, the quality and microbial safety of beef, lamb, pork, venison, and bison resulting from different chilling treatments has been reviewed, as well as the underlying mechanism(s) for the different impacts on meat quality traits as a result of different chilling regimes. The effect of fast chilling on the tenderness of beef and lamb is a focus, as some new findings, have recently been reported, while multistep chilling is highlighted as it incorporates the advantages of fast chilling to reduce carcass weight loss, resulting in similar quality improvements as found with slow chilling. It is, suggested, that if spray chilling can be combined with the second phase of multi‐step chilling, it will benefit the meat industry in terms of both meat quality and safety. Future studies should focus on combinations of chilling methods with new technologies, such as medium voltage electrical stimulation, muscle stretching, or ultrasound and so on, to move meat quality and safety to a new level.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.