Effects of educational mismatch on private returns to education: An analysis of the Spanish case (1995–2006)

Abstract

Esta es la versión de autor del artículo publicado en: This is an author produced version of a paper published in:Journal of Policy Modeling 34 (2012) This study examines the effects of educational mismatch on wages in the Spanish labour market since the mid-nineties. First we study the evolution of returns to education and then we estimate returns to education in terms of the match between the worker's schooling and the job requirements. The results indicate that returns to education have declined since the mid-nineties. One also finds that the return associated with the job's required education is greater than that corresponding to the worker's actual schooling, and that the return on an additional year of attained education is positive but less than that of an additional year of required education. From a policy perspective, the existence of educational mismatch points to inefficiencies in the allocation of the educational resources. Investment on education can positively contribute to alleviate the unemployment problem in Spain, but taken into account the existence of educational mismatch it also becomes necessary to introduce structural reforms in order to adapt the job structure to a model of production based on knowledge so that the more highly qualified workers can find a job that corresponds to their educational level.JEL classification: I20; I29; J30

Sheepskin Effects in the Returns to Higher Education: New Evidence for Malaysia

“…This results are supportive of signalling hypothesis that claims the declining return to education is due to the inability of the highly educated to persistently maintain their productivity-unrelated earnings advantage over the less educated (Groot & Oosterbeek, 1994;Spence, 1973). Many evidences supporting the returns for workers fall because they might be dissatisfied with their current job and dropped their productivity level in the firm (Green & Zhu, 2010;Murillo, Rahona-López, & Salinas-Jiménez, 2012;Verhaest & Omey, 2006 For the second phase, 2007-2012, the estimation result in Table 4 showed that the trend of average private returns increased for all certificates except for LCE in 2007-2012. The results indicated that the employers might pay for certificates if they adequately signal worker productivity; that is, if they act as proper sheepskins.…”

Overeducation, Skills and Wage Penalty: Evidence for Spain Using PIAAC Data

“…Although there is a wide literature analysing the impact of overeducation on wages in Spain (see AlbaRamírez, 1993;Murillo et al 2012;Nieto and Ramos, 2013; among others), to our knowledge, no extensive analysis has tested the role of individuals' skill level on educational mismatch focusing on the Spanish case. Participation in the problem-solving domain was optional, and Spain (and other countries) did not participate in it.…”

Educational Mismatch and Cognitive Skills: Effects on Wages

“…Para una revisión de esta literatura véase, por ejemplo, Hartog (2000) o McGuiness (2006). Estudios recientes para el caso español puede encontrarse en Murillo et al (2012) y nieto y Ramos (2013).…”