Effects of demographic, occupational, and practice environment variables on organizational silence among nurse managers

Abstract

To define nurse managers' organizational silence behaviors and examine the demographic, occupational, and practice environment factors that may influence their silence. Background: Organizational silence is affected by organizational structures, policies and procedures, team structures, and practice environments. Whether nurse managers' behaviors affect the organizational silence and practice environment in particular has not been thoroughly studied. Methods: This cross-sectional study was conducted using an online survey of 169 nurse managers working in a group of private hospitals in Turkey. Data were collected using the Nurse Manager Practice Environment Scale, the Organizational Silence Behavior Scale, and a questionnaire with 16 sociodemographic and job-related questions, and descriptive statistics, correlations, and regression analyses were used to analyze the data. Results: Nurse managers exhibited acquiescent silence and silence for the protection of the organization. There was a negative correlation between scores on the two scales. Regression analysis showed that nurse managers' organizational silence was affected by the two subscales of nurse managers' practice environment and the ability to express opinions openly. Conclusion:Positive work environment and being able to express opinions comfortably decrease the level of organizational silence of nurse managers. Implications for nursing and health policy: In order to reduce organizational silence behaviors, along with open-door policies and a corporate culture where ideas can be expressed freely, health institutions should implement measures to ensure a positive work environment that empowers administrative leaders to create a culture of patient safety and culture of generativity. Regulating the roles and responsibilities of nurse managers at the institutional level and implementing appropriate nursing laws and regulations at the national level will facilitate changes to improve their management practices.

Work environment, resilience, burnout, intent to leave during COVID pandemic among nurse leaders: A cross‐sectional study

“…Weiner‐Lastinger and colleagues reported a significant increase of central–line–associated bloodstream infections, catheter‐associated urinary tract infections, ventilator associated events, and methicillin‐resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) nationwide (Weiner‐Lastinger et al, 2022 ). However, when we compared our findings to the international study (Aslan et al, 2022 ), our sample reported lower scores in all subscales of the work environment except Fair and Manageable Workload. This could be explained by the different hospital types and presence of the COVID‐19 pandemic in our study (mostly public hospitals during COVID‐19 pandemic) versus the Turkish study (only private hospital and prior to the pandemic) (Aslan et al, 2022 ).…”

“…However, when we compared our findings to the international study (Aslan et al, 2022 ), our sample reported lower scores in all subscales of the work environment except Fair and Manageable Workload. This could be explained by the different hospital types and presence of the COVID‐19 pandemic in our study (mostly public hospitals during COVID‐19 pandemic) versus the Turkish study (only private hospital and prior to the pandemic) (Aslan et al, 2022 ).…”

An integrative systematic review of employee silence and voice in healthcare: what are we really measuring?

“…The Yalcin and Baykal ( 40 ) scale for employee silence antecedents was used in two studies (2.6% of the 76 studies) ( 40 , 108 ). This scale required the participants to indicate the frequency of remaining silent due to reasons related to silence climate, silence based on fear, acquiescent silence and silence based on protecting the organization.…”

Navigating the Challenges of Education Management Best Practices for Improving Student Outcomes

“…Education policy and funding decisions can greatly impact the ability of schools to meet their goals and deliver high-quality education to students. Education managers must be able to know about the policy environment and be able to effectively advocate for policies that support the needs of students and schools (Aslan, et al, 2022). Furthermore, education managers must also be able to effectively manage cultural diversity and support students from diverse backgrounds.…”