Analyses were made of the effects of extraction of the 17,24 kilodalton extrinsic proteins from spinach versus wheat photosystem II (PSII) membranes on Ca abundance and 02 evolution capacity determined in the absence and presence of either ClO or Ca22. Extraction of these proteins from spinach PSII routinely diminished steady state 02 evolution by about 70% when assayed in the presence ofsufficient Cl1. Additionally, 02 evolution of 17,24 kilodalton-less spinach PSI1 membranes showed about 2-fold more enhancement by Ca22 than by Cl-during assay. When the same extraction and assay procedures were applied to wheat PSII membranes, we observed, in contrast to 17,24 kilodalton-less spinach PSII, only about 50% inhibition of 02 evolution and about 2-fold greater enhancement by Cl-than by Ca21. Irrespective of differences in the magnitude of enhancement of 02 evolution by Ca2' versuC a-in spinach versus wheat, the K., values for Cl-(about 1.7 millimolar) and Ca2l (about 1.5 millimolar) were similar for both type preparations. The abundance of Ca specifically associated with fully functional PSII (about 2 and about 3 Ca/200 chlorophyll for spinach and wheat, respectively) was diminished to about 1 per 200 chlorophyll upon 17.24 kilodalton protein depletion. Further treatment of wheat 17,24 kilodalton-less PSII in darkness with 2 molar NaClI/ millimolar ethyleneglycol-bis(O-aminoethyl ether)-N,N'-tetraacetic acid/20 micromolar A231872 made 02 evolution highly dependent on Ca2 addition, much like the 17,24 kilodaltonless spinach PSII. Analyses of this Ca2' effect on 02 evolution revealed both high (K. about 65 micromolar) and low (K. about 1.5 millimolar) affinity Ca2 sites in wheat 17,24 kilodalton-less PSII. The results suggest that during 17,24 kilodalton extraction by NaCl, spinach PSII is more susceptible than wheat PSII to loss of high affinity Ca and irreversible inhibition of 02 evolution.The realization of 02 evolving everted thylakoid vesicles (1, 21) and Triton X-100 prepared PSII membranes (3, 24), also having everted membrane orientation (14,24), has led to intensive research focused on defining the polypeptides essential for efficient functioning of the PSII/water oxidizing complex. Parallel research has been directed towards identifying which poly- 90% (4-7, 15, 16, 21, 25, 27) when determined in the presence of saturating concentrations of Cl-. Subsequently, it was shown (6,7,15,16) that addition of 10 to 20 mM Ca2+ to 17,24 kDless, Cl-sufficient spinach PSII membranes increased rates of 02 evolution as much as 4-to 6-fold to rates sometimes nearly equivalent to those observed with unextracted membranes. However, no Ca2' additions were necessary to observe substantial period-4 oscillations of the S-states with only about 25% disconnection of the S-state complexes from PSII traps (12).Conceivably, at least some of the rather large variability in extent of loss of 02 evolution following depletion of the 17,24 kD proteins could reflect inadvertent dissociation of high affinity Ca2`during extraction....