Effects of Changes to Architectural Elements on Human Relaxation-Arousal Responses: Based on VR and EEG

Abstract

This study combines electroencephalogram (EEG) with virtual reality (VR) technologies to measure the EEG responses of users experiencing changes to architectural elements. We analyze the ratio of alpha to beta waves (RAB) indicators to determine the pre- and poststimulation changes. In our methodology, thirty-three females experience using private rooms in a postpartum care center participated in the experiment. Their brain waves are measured while they are experiencing the VR space of a private room in a postpartum care center. Three architectural elements (i.e., aspect ratio of space, ceiling height, and window ratio) are varied in the VR space. In addition, a self-report questionnaire is administered to examine whether the responses are consistent with the results of the EEG response analysis. As a result, statistically significant differences (p < 0.05) are observed in the changes in the RAB indicator values of the pre- and poststimulation EEG while the subjects are experiencing the VR space where the architectural elements are varied. That is, the effects of the changes to architectural elements on users’ relaxation-arousal responses are statistically verified. Notably, in all the RAB indicator values where significant differences are observed, the poststimulation RAB decreases in comparison to the prestimulus ratios, which is indicative of the arousal response. However, the arousal levels vary across the architectural elements, which implies it would be possible to find out the elements that could induce less arousal response using the proposed method. Moreover, following the experience in the VR space, certain lobes of the brain (F4 and P3 EEG channels) show statistically significant differences in the relaxation-arousal responses. Unlike previous studies, which measured users’ physiological responses to abstract and primordial spatial elements, this study extends the boundaries of the literature by applying the architectural elements applicable to design in practice.

Evaluation of the Impact of Rural Streetscape Enhancement on Relaxation-Arousal Responses Based on EEG and VR

“…Other studies have also demonstrated that a street scene that is more diverse and less fragmented leads to positive emotional experiences 16 . Furthermore, the observed variations in relaxation levels across the three groups further indicate that distinct street scales have an impact on individuals' pleasant moods, which is like previous research demonstrating that the scale of indoor spaces can elicit either good or negative physiological reactions in users 27 .…”

Adequate Green: A Study on the Impact of Continuous Green Landscape, Both Indoors and Outdoors, on the Physiological and Psychological Recovery of Adolescents

“…One is the alpha waves (8-12 Hz), which appear in the state of relaxed consciousness, and the other is the beta waves (12-30 Hz), which appear in a state of active and focused thinking [19]. These EEG indicators, along with specific channels, can serve as biomarkers for analyzing relaxation and wakefulness responses in real-time, such as the RAB: α/β Ratio indicators and EEG channels F4 and F3 [20]. The Restorative Outcome Scale is a self-assessment tool for measuring emotional recovery and is extensively utilized in the field of recovery research..…”

Neurosciences in Architecture: Applied Research and its Potential in Architectural Design

“…In 2021 Kim et al (2021) published a study on the effects of changes in architectural spaces on human responses on the relaxation-awakening plane based on VR and EEG. The study included private rooms in a postpartum care centre, presented in the form of a VR model.…”