Effects of Age on Melody and Timbre Perception in Simulations of Electro-Acoustic and Cochlear-Implant Hearing

Abstract

Objectives Recent evidence suggests that age might affect the ability of listeners to process fundamental frequency cues in speech, and that this difficulty might impact the ability of older listeners to use and combine envelope and fine structure cues available in simulations of electro-acoustic and cochlear-implant hearing. The purpose of this paper is to examine whether this difficulty extends to music. Specially, this study focuses on whether older listeners have a decreased ability to utilize and combine different types of cues in the perception of melody and timbre. Design A group of older listeners with normal to near-normal hearing and a group of younger listeners with normal hearing participated in the melody and timbre recognition tasks of the University of Washington Clinical Assessment of Music Perception (CAMP) test. The recognition tasks were completed for five different processing conditions: 1) an unprocessed condition; 2) an eight-channel vocoding condition that simulated a traditional cochlear implant and contained temporal envelope cues; 3) a simulation of electro-acoustic stimulation (sEAS) that included a low-pass acoustic component and high-pass vocoded portion, and which provided fine structure and envelope cues; 4) a condition that included only the low-pass acoustic portion of the sEAS and 5) a condition that included only the high-frequency vocoded portion of the sEAS stimulus. Results Melody recognition was excellent for both younger and older listeners in the conditions containing the unprocessed stimuli, the full sEAS stimuli, and the low-pass sEAS stimuli. Melody recognition was significantly worse in the cochlear-implant simulation condition, especially for the older group of listeners. Performance on the timbre task was highest for the unprocessed condition, and progressively decreased for the sEAS and cochlear-implant simulation conditions. Compared to younger listeners, older listeners had significantly poorer timbre recognition for all processing conditions. For melody recognition, the unprocessed low-frequency portion of the sEAS stimulus was the primary factor determining improved performance in the sEAS condition compared to the cochlear-implant simulation. For timbre recognition, both the unprocessed low-frequency and high-frequency vocoded portions of the sEAS stimulus contributed to sEAS improvement in the younger group. In contrast, most listeners in the older group were not able to take advantage of the high-frequency vocoded portion of the sEAS stimulus for timbre recognition. Conclusions The results of this simulation study support the idea that older listeners will have diminished timbre and melody perception in traditional cochlear-implant listening due to degraded envelope processing. The findings also suggest that music perception by older listeners with cochlear implants will be improved with the addition of low-frequency residual hearing. However, these improvements might not be comparable for all dimensions of music perception. That is, more improvement ...

Reduction of the Harmonic Series Influences Musical Enjoyment With Cochlear Implants

“…Therefore, even though the fundamental frequency dominates listeners’ aural perception, they are, in reality, simultaneously hearing several different complimentary frequencies. 13 Harmonics are a significant component of musical timbre and thus help distinguish one instrument from another. These naturally occurring overtone frequencies may make a considerable contribution to the aural complexity of music and increase the number of signals that the CI must process and transmit.…”

Differences in Perception of Musical Stimuli among Acoustic, Electric, and Combined Modality Listeners

“…A potential limitation for this study is the mismatch in age between groups, as it has been documented that older adults have poorer timbre perception than younger adults when listening through a simulated CI (Arehart et al, 2014). As mentioned above, the average age for the NH group is significantly younger than all other hearing-impaired groups, and a significant correlation was observed between age and performance on timbre perception.…”

Melodic Contour Identification Reflects the Cognitive Threshold of Aging

“…This interpretation is very similar to those of previous studies that reported that listening to multilayered sounds, as an example of a cocktail party effect, is quite challenging with aging ( Heine and Browning, 2002 ; Parbery-Clark et al, 2009b , 2011 ). A person’s ASA capacity rapidly decreases with aging, leading to loss of speech comprehension ( Grassi and Borella, 2013 ; Arehart et al, 2014 ).…”

“…In this sense, selective attention is also examined. Hence, given that timbre discrimination is highly associated with speech perception in aging ( Zhu et al, 2011 ; Grassi and Borella, 2013 ; Arehart et al, 2014 ), timbre discrimination and selective attention can sufficiently indicate age-related communication skills.…”