Effectiveness of Musculoskeletal Education Interventions in People With Low Literacy Levels: A Systematic Review

Abstract

ObjectiveTo conduct a systematic review to assess the effectiveness of patient education interventions delivered or directed by health professionals for people with musculoskeletal conditions who also have lower levels of literacy.MethodsElectronic databases were searched from 1946 to May 2012. Randomized controlled trials with primary interventions designed specifically for individuals with musculoskeletal conditions and lower levels of literacy were eligible for inclusion. The quality of the study was determined by assessing method of randomization, allocation concealment, creation and maintenance of comparable groups, blinding of patients and providers, control of confounding, and the validity and reliability of outcome measures.ResultsOf the 2,440 studies located using the search strategy, 6 studies met the inclusion criteria. Three public health community studies and 3 rheumatology clinic-based studies delivered educational programs to people with musculoskeletal conditions who also had lower levels of literacy. Three moderate quality studies suggest that musculoskeletal educational interventions had a small short-term effect on knowledge and 2 moderate quality studies suggest musculoskeletal interventions had a small effect on self-efficacy (although results on self-efficacy were conflicting in 1 of these studies). Only 1 moderate quality study showed a small effect on anxiety and 1 on self-perceived health and well-being in people with lower literacy.ConclusionHigh quality evidence is lacking on the effectiveness of musculoskeletal education interventions for people with lower literacy levels. Research programs that test the effectiveness of patient education interventions for arthritis must recruit and engage people with lower levels of literacy.

The accessibility and usability of an Australian web‐based self‐management programme for people with lower health literacy and joint pain in the UK: A qualitative interview study

“…These results indicate there is still discrepancy between the depth and coverage of healthcare information provided. Health literacy has a significant impact on self‐management behaviours (Ishikawa & Yano, ) and our findings confirm that provision of health information is often too complicated for universal understanding (Chapman et al, in press; Coulter & Ellins, ; Lowe et al, ). Our results add further evidence to research about the impact of disengagement with health advice when the message is unclear (Ware, Wyatt, Geng, Kaaya, & Agbaji, ).…”

“…People with OA should be provided with self‐management strategies to promote healthy lifestyles and maintain function (Clark et al, ; National Collaborating Centre for Chronic Conditions (UK), ; Pinto, Robertson, Hansen, & Abbott, ). The success of self‐management education is not equitable for all patient groups (Lowe et al, ). Healthcare information is often too complex for patients to understand (Rowlands et al, ).…”

‘What I Really Needed Was the Truth’. Exploring the Information Needs of People with Complex Regional Pain Syndrome

“…If our participants, with higher literacy and educational levels, were frustrated by a lack of knowledge and awareness and had to rely on their own research, then this may represent the ‘best‐case scenario’ for people using the National Health Service (NHS). People with lower literacy levels are known to do less well when using the NHS for long‐term conditions (Lowe et al, ). There was the potential for the researcher to be known to participants through her role at a CRPS specialist centre; however, this was only the case for one participant.…”

Role of Health Literacy in Self-Reported Musculoskeletal Disorders

“…However, the evidence for some of these strategies in musculoskeletal diseases is limited, as highlighted by a recent systematic review which found a lack of high-quality evidence on the effectiveness of musculoskeletal education interventions for people with lower literacy levels [27]. A recent randomized controlled trial of an intervention to reduce low literacy barriers in inflammatory arthritis management showed no benefit on outcomes [28].…”