Effectiveness of Artificial Intelligence Methods in Personalized Aggression Risk Prediction within Inpatient Psychiatric Treatment Settings—A Systematic Review

Abstract

Aggression risk assessments are vital to prevent injuries and morbidities amongst patients and staff in psychiatric settings. More recent studies have harnessed artificial intelligence (AI) methods such as machine learning algorithms to determine factors associated with aggression in psychiatric treatment settings. In this review, using Cooper’s five-stage review framework, we aimed to evaluate the: (1) predictive accuracy, and (2) clinical variables associated with AI-based aggression risk prediction amongst psychiatric inpatients. Databases including PubMed, Cochrane, Scopus, PsycINFO, CINAHL were searched for relevant articles until April 2022. The eight included studies were independently evaluated using critical appraisal tools for systematic review developed by Joanna Briggs Institute. Most of the studies (87.5%) examined health records in predicting aggression and reported acceptable to excellent accuracy with specific machine learning algorithms employed (area under curve range 0.75–0.87). No particular machine learning algorithm outperformed the others consistently across studies (area under curve range 0.61–0.87). Relevant factors identified with aggression related to demographic and social profile, past aggression, forensic history, other psychiatric history, psychopathology, challenging behaviors and management domains. The limited extant studies have highlighted a potential role for the use of AI methods to clarify factors associated with aggression in psychiatric inpatient treatment settings.

Machine Learning for prediction of violent behaviors in schizophrenia spectrum disorders: a systematic review

“…Previous research has shown an acceptable power for ML models in predicting VB in populations broader than SSD patients ( 68 , 69 ). In this article, we reviewed the role of ML in predicting VB in patients with SSD.…”

“…patients (68,69). In this article, we reviewed the role of ML in predicting VB in patients with SSD.…”

Testamentary capacity assessment in dementia using artificial intelligence: prospects and challenges

“…The role of AI in forensic psychiatry has received increased attention in recent years, with the majority of studies coming from the area of predicting violence risk in patients in psychiatric institutions or in people held in custody, e.g., [( 30–34 ); review by ( 35 )], and a review on the controversial topic of use of brain reading AI for neuroprediction of violence by Tortora et al ( 36 ), and the prediction of future offenses and dangerousness in persons with psychiatric disorders, e.g., [( 37 , 38 ); review by ( 39 )]. The advantage of ML is that it can combine large numbers of data and investigate large numbers of predictors in nonlinear and interactive ways.…”