Effectiveness of a strategy that uses educational games to implement clinical practice guidelines among Spanish residents of family and community medicine (e-EDUCAGUIA project): a clinical trial by clusters

Abstract

BackgroundClinical practice guidelines (CPGs) have been developed with the aim of helping health professionals, patients, and caregivers make decisions about their health care, using the best available evidence. In many cases, incorporation of these recommendations into clinical practice also implies a need for changes in routine clinical practice. Using educational games as a strategy for implementing recommendations among health professionals has been demonstrated to be effective in some studies; however, evidence is still scarce. The primary objective of this study is to assess the effectiveness of a teaching strategy for the implementation of CPGs using educational games (e-learning EDUCAGUIA) to improve knowledge and skills related to clinical decision-making by residents in family medicine. The primary objective will be evaluated at 1 and 6 months after the intervention. The secondary objectives are to identify barriers and facilitators for the use of guidelines by residents of family medicine and to describe the educational strategies used by Spanish teaching units of family and community medicine to encourage implementation of CPGs.Methods/designWe propose a multicenter clinical trial with randomized allocation by clusters of family and community medicine teaching units in Spain. The sample size will be 394 residents (197 in each group), with the teaching units as the randomization unit and the residents comprising the analysis unit. For the intervention, both groups will receive an initial 1-h session on clinical practice guideline use and the usual dissemination strategy by e-mail. The intervention group (e-learning EDUCAGUIA) strategy will consist of educational games with hypothetical clinical scenarios in a virtual environment.The primary outcome will be the score obtained by the residents on evaluation questionnaires for each clinical practice guideline. Other included variables will be the sociodemographic and training variables of the residents and the teaching unit characteristics. The statistical analysis will consist of a descriptive analysis of variables and a baseline comparison of both groups. For the primary outcome analysis, an average score comparison of hypothetical scenario questionnaires between the EDUCAGUIA intervention group and the control group will be performed at 1 and 6 months post-intervention, using 95 % confidence intervals. A linear multilevel regression will be used to adjust the model.DiscussionThe identification of effective teaching strategies will facilitate the incorporation of available knowledge into clinical practice that could eventually improve patient outcomes. The inclusion of information technologies as teaching tools permits greater learning autonomy and allows deeper instructor participation in the monitoring and supervision of residents. The long-term impact of this strategy is unknown; however, because it is aimed at professionals undergoing training and it addresses prevalent health problems, a small effect can be of great relevance.Trial registrationClin...

Effectiveness of a serious game addressing guideline adherence: cohort study with 1.5-year follow-up

“…academic publications and books), clinical reasoning can best be trained by repeated exposure to real patient cases [ 24 ]. It has been suggested that e-learning can be an effective tool for implementing clinical practice guidelines [ 25 ], and a multicentre clinical trial testing this hypothesis is currently underway [ 26 ].…”

Model-Driven Automatic Question Generation for a Gamified Clinical Guideline Training System

“…In Portugal Del Cura-Gonzalez et al conducted a study to assess the effectiveness of a teaching strategy for the implementation of clinical guidelines using educational games [8]. They presented the findings for the use of an e-learning game EDUCAGUIA to improve knowledge and skills related to clinical decision-making by residents in family medicine.…”

“…Such evaluation is very important and it reflects the usefulness of utilizing games in teaching guidelines. We plan to conduct similar evaluation of our gamification approach with healthcare professionals in future [8].…”

Experiencias en la formación de médicos familiares en la modalidad a distancia y virtual: una posibilidad para el sistema de salud colombiano

“…En España, en la experiencia de Melús-Palazón, et al (41), se usó un ambiente social virtual para realizar conferencias, y se señala que las sociedades que agremian a los médicos familiares son importantes para mejorar la aceptación de los programas de educación a distancia entre ellos, así como para fomentar una relación de compañerismo, respeto y colaboración entre colegas y las capacidades para compartir conocimientos con sus pares (42). Paralelo a esto, en Colombia los médicos familiares se agremian en la Sociedad Colombiana de Medicina Familiar (SOCMEF), la cual tiene entre sus estatutos, participar junto con otras instituciones en los procesos formativos de los especialistas.…”