Effectiveness of a Brief Teaching Scenario in a Phantom-Based Learning Model for Students to Achieve Ultrasound-Guided Vascular Access—a Prospective Study

Abstract

For students, early hands-on experience is very limited and often non-existent during study time. Thus, we aimed to evaluate the progress of inexperienced medical students in successfully establishing an ultrasound-guided vessel access. One brief, condensed single teaching lesson in a prior to post-teaching scenario was performed using an inexpensive, self-made phantom model. In this prospective study, medical students (n = 11) with no experience in ultrasound imaging performed an ultrasound-guided vessel access simulated by a gelatin-based phantom model. Success rates and time of procedures were measured. Afterwards, participants underwent dedicated supervised teaching in a single lesson (duration 30 min) with both theoretical information given and practical training skills shown. Then, every student performed the very same procedure again and results were compared with paired t test. Success rate of guide wire placement rose from 36.4 (4/11) to 100%. Mean number of attempts significantly decreased with 2.5 SD1.3 before and 1.2 SD0.4 after teaching (p < 0.05). Overall time to successful guide wire placement improved from 291 SD8 to 151 SD37 s (p < 0.05). With already limited training time and opportunities available during medical education, short and simple, but highly effective training tools are invaluable. With the help of an inexpensive, self-made gelatin-based phantom model for ultrasound-guided vascular access, medical students demonstrate significantly improved practical puncture skills after only one brief, condensed teaching lesson and thus an important progress with regard to their future clinical routine. The performance of ultrasound-guided vascular access can be highly improved for inexperienced medical students by applying one short teaching session using an inexpensive, self-made phantom model.

Development and Evaluation of Doppler Ultrasound Training Phantom for Human Vessel Simulation

“…Through actively identifying and correcting errors, it is possible to improve the accuracy and diagnostic skills. However, it is worth noting that most training phantoms available are primarily designed for physician education, specifically for biopsies [10][11][12].…”

Measuring the Compression Force Required for Vascular Shortening in Ultrasonic Vascular Models

“…Therefore, various homemade vascular models using three-dimensional (3D) printers, tofu, gelatin bases, etc. have been reported, but they are not widely used [9][10][11][12][13]. We utilize ultrasound practice, ultrasound training block, and central venous models for vein delineation practice, but the thickness and brightness of the vessels vary from model to model.…”