Effectiveness and Cost-Effectiveness of Occupation-Based Occupational Therapy Using the Aid for Decision Making in Occupation Choice (ADOC) for Older Residents: Pilot Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial

Abstract

BackgroundCare-home residents are mostly inactive, have little interaction with staff, and are dependent on staff to engage in daily occupations. We recently developed an iPad application called the Aid for Decision-making in Occupation Choice (ADOC) to promote shared decision-making in activities and occupation-based goal setting by choosing from illustrations describing daily activities. This study aimed to evaluate if interventions based on occupation-based goal setting using the ADOC could focus on meaningful activities to improve quality of life and independent activities of daily living, with greater cost-effectiveness than an impairment-based approach as well as to evaluate the feasibility of conducting a large cluster, randomized controlled trial.MethodIn this single (assessor)-blind pilot cluster randomized controlled trial, the intervention group (ADOC group) received occupational therapy based on occupation-based goal setting using the ADOC, and the interventions were focused on meaningful occupations. The control group underwent an impairment-based approach focused on restoring capacities, without goal setting tools. In both groups, the 20-minute individualized intervention sessions were conducted twice a week for 4 months.Main Outcome MeasuresShort Form-36 (SF-36) score, SF-6D utility score, quality adjusted life years (QALY), Barthel Index, and total care cost.ResultsWe randomized and analyzed 12 facilities (44 participants, 18.5% drop-out rate), with 6 facilities each allocated to the ADOC (n = 23) and control (n = 21) groups. After the 4-month intervention, the ADOC group had a significantly greater change in the BI score, with improved scores (P = 0.027, 95% CI 0.41 to 6.87, intracluster correlation coefficient = 0.14). No other outcome was significantly different. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, calculated using the change in BI score, was $63.1.ConclusionThe results suggest that occupational therapy using the ADOC for older residents might be effective and cost-effective. We also found that conducting an RCT in the occupational therapy setting is feasible.Trial RegistrationUMIN Clinical Trials Registry UMIN000012994

Relative efficiency of unequal versus equal cluster sizes in cluster randomized trials using generalized estimating equation models

“…In recent years, there has been growing interest in conducting cluster randomized trials (CRTs) (Campbell et al, 2000; Gulliford et al, 2014; Gravenstein et al, 2016; Kalfon et al, 2016; Mehring et al, 2016; Nagayama et al, 2016; Yamagata et al, 2016). CRTs are performed when randomization at the individual-level is practically infeasible or may lead to severe estimation bias of treatment effect.…”

Optimal designs in three‐level cluster randomized trials with a binary outcome

“…Following the same definition of RE, 17 the ratio of the variance of each measure estimator for practice size n LOD to n, we use Equations (5), (8), and (12) and then define RE for measure RD as a function of n, r, and ρ, ie,…”

“…1,2 Therefore, there has been growing interest in the design of CRTs. [3][4][5][6][7][8][9] The unit of randomization might be hospitals, clinics, classrooms, etc. Subjects within a cluster are exposed to common factors and tend to share similar characteristics.…”

iPad Use in Stroke Neuro-Rehabilitation

“…As well as improved clinical outcomes, qualitative data highlighted positive overall experience from all patients participating in iPad-based rehabilitation. Nagayama et al (2016) recently developed an iPad application (Decision-making in Occupation Choice (ADOC)) showing statistically significant (p = 0.027) improvement in Barthel Index in a single-blinded RCT for care-home elderly residents [43]. Rand et al (2013) pilot study explored the feasibility and suitability of varying iPad applications in improving post-stroke hand impairment.…”