Effectiveness and cost effectiveness of palliative care interventions in people with chronic heart failure and their caregivers: a systematic review

Abstract

Background Chronic heart failure is a common condition, and its prevalence is expected to rise significantly over the next two decades. Research demonstrates the increasing multidimensional needs of patients and caregivers. However, access to palliative care services for this population has remained poor. This systematic review was to provide an evidence synthesis of the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of palliative care interventions for people with chronic heart failure and their caregivers. Methods Relevant publications were identified via electronic searches of MEDLINE, Embase, PsychInfo, CINAHL, CENTRAL and HMIC from inception to June 2019. Grey literature databases, reference list, and citations of key review articles were also searched. Quality was assessed using the Revised Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool. Results Of the 2083 records, 18 studies were identified including 17 having randomised controlled trial (RCT) designs and one mixed methods study with an RCT component. There was significant heterogeneity in study settings, control groups, interventions delivered, and outcome measures used. The most commonly assessed outcome measures were functional status (n = 9), psychological symptoms (n = 9), disease-specific quality of life (n = 9), and physical symptom control (n = 8). The outcome measures with the greatest evidence for benefit included general and disease-specific quality of life, psychological symptom control, satisfaction with care, physical symptom control, medical utilisation, and caregiver burden. Moreover, the methodological quality of these studies was mixed, with only four having an overall low risk of bias and the remaining studies either demonstrating high risk of bias (n = 10) or showing some concerns (n = 4) due to small sample sizes and poor retention. Only two studies reported on economic costs. Both found statistically significant results showing the intervention group to be more cost effective than the control group, but the quality of both studies was at high risk of bias. Conclusions This review supports the role of palliative care interventions in patients with chronic heart failure and their caregivers across various outcomes, particularly quality of life and psychological wellbeing. Due to the highly heterogeneous nature of palliative care interventions, it is not possible to provide definitive recommendations as to what guise palliative care interventions should take to best support the complex care of this population. Considerable future research, particularly focusing on quality of care after death and the caregiver population, is warranted.

Enhancing Quality of Life in Pediatric Palliative Care: Insights, Challenges, and Future Directions—A Systematic Review

“…As emphasized by Hicks et al [64], the organization of multidisciplinary services holds paramount importance in palliative care. However, it is crucial to acknowledge that QOL, being subjective and individual, demands personalized responses tailored to each child's specifc circumstances.…”

Integration of palliative care across the spectrum of heart failure care and therapies: considerations, contemporary data, and challenges

“…A number of studies and trials have examined the effectiveness of various multidisciplinary PC interventions for patients with HF (Table 1) [35]. Overall, the outcomes with the greatest evidence base include health-related quality of life and physical and psychological symptoms [2][3][4]36].…”

Bretxa Digital a l'Educació d'Alumnat Pal·liatiu: L'Omissió de les Tecnologies Emergents

“…La investigación y el desarrollo en este ámbito deben ute | 2024 Núm. 2 e3677 ser interdisciplinarios, involucrando a expertos en tecnología, pedagogía, medicina y psicología (Hicks et al, 2022). Esta colaboración es esencial para garantizar que las soluciones tecnológicas sean efectivas y seguras desde una perspectiva médica, psicológica y pedagógica.…”