“…In a one-dimensional model [5,6,8,9], contrary to the experiment [2], the bunches with step-up drift grow slower than those with step-down drift. In a twodimensional model [7,11], the bunches wander heavily and recombine with neighboring bunches with step-up drift. The growth rate is accelerated by the recombination and becomes faster than that with step-down drift as in the experiment [2].…”