“…On the other hand, an interesting dual effect of solids on gas holdup has also been observed (Kara et al, 1982;Pandit and Joshi, 1984;Sada et al, 1986 a,b;Bukur et al, 1990;Khare and Joshi, 1990;Jamialahmadi and Muller-Steinhagen, 1991;Garcia-Ochoa et al, 1997;Xie et al, 2003, see also Table 1 in Banisi et al, 1995a), indicating the presence of two counteracting physical mechanisms. Besides the above mentioned drop in voidage with solids, Kara et al (1982) also find a subtle opposite effect: ".…”