To investigate the influences of discrete fiber strips on the mechanical properties of reinforced sand, a series of direct shear tests were conducted. A method to strictly control the initial orientation of fiber strips in specimen preparation was developed. Under the same normal pressure, the peak strength of sand specimens was proportional to the fiber content and was inversely proportional to the fiber initial orientation angle. The influences of initial fiber orientation on peak strength may depend on the stress mobilization in fibers. When the fiber strips distributed at a certain orientation angle were subjected to tensile stress in shearing, they could play an effective role in the peak strength gain of sand and vice versa. Due to the restriction of fibers on the volume dilation of sand specimens, the residual strength of reinforced sand also increased. However, the initial stiffness of reinforced sand was smaller than that of pure sand, which may be related to the precompression of flexible fiber strips and the density inhomogeneity of specimens induced in the specimen preparation process. In addition, the ductility of sand specimens was improved by the introduction of fiber strips, intuitively reflected by the increase in displacement failure. This may also be attributed to the restriction of fiber strips on the deformation of sand specimens.