“…In free-operant studies, the periodic withdrawal of positive reinforcing stimuli such as coins (e.g., Baron & Kaufman, 1966), point loss (e.g., Weiner, 1963), and cartoons (e.g., Baer, 1960) , as well as the presentation of noxious stimuli such as electric shock (e.g., Ader & Tatum , 1961) and white noise (e.g., Presbie, 1970) have been used. In discrete-trial avoidance experiments, electric shock (e.g., Banks, 1965), loud tones (e.g., Penny & Croskery, 1962), and air blasts (e.g., Miller, Kalin, Eckenroth, & Meyer, 1970) have been the most commonly used noxious stimuli . In addition, withdrawal of positive reinforcing stimuli such as children's stories (Moffat, 1972) and entertaining material (e.g., Moffat & Miller, 1970) have been employed effectively as aversive stimuli in discrete-trial avoidance conditioning experiments.…”