Effect of malpractice claims on orthopedic and traumatology physicians in Turkey: A survey study

Abstract

Objective This study aimed to investigate the malpractice claims experienced by orthopedic and traumatology physicians and to determine their effects on burnout, job satisfaction, and clinical practice. Methods A questionnaire survey was conducted on orthopedic and traumatology specialists between May 2019 and February 2020. Data collection was carried out via e-survey at “turk-ortopedi” mail group, which is an electronic communication network of orthopedic and traumatology physicians. For data collection, sociodemographic data forms were used including the general characteristics, working conditions, and the malpractice claim events along with the Maslach Burnout Inventory scale to evaluate burnout and the Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire to investigate job satisfaction. Results In total, 353 orthopedic and traumatology physicians (348 men, 5 women), including 37 professors, 41 associate professors, and 275 surgeons, completed the questionnaire. In total, 65.4% of the participants (231 physicians and 471 relevant dossiers) stated that they were currently facing a malpractice claim. Emotional burnout and hesitant behavior in medical practices were significantly higher among the physicians who had undergone an investigation/trial with the claim of malpractice (p<0.05), whereas intrinsic job satisfaction was significantly lower (p<0.05). It was determined that orthopedic and traumatology physicians dealing with arthroplasty, vertebral surgery, hand surgery, and foot/ankle surgeries had undergone significantly more trials (p<0.05). In the evaluation of the burnout levels and job satisfaction scores of the physicians according to the age, academic title, seniority, and institution, it was determined that burnout level decreased with age, those between the ages of 25 and 34 years were exhausted the most, and job satisfaction increased with age. It was also found that burnout level decreased and job satisfaction increased as the academic title became higher, and attending physicians were the most exhausted. Moreover, burnout level decreased as seniority increased, the most senior ones were the ones most exhausted, and job satisfaction increased with seniority. Conclusion Evidence from this study has revealed that malpractice claims cause emotional burnout, low intrinsic job satisfaction, and a hesitant behavior in medical practice for the orthopedic and traumatology physicians. The concept of malpractice alone may result in unnecessary analyses/examinations for patients. Level of Evidence Level IV, Diagnostic Study

Association of job characteristics and burnout of healthcare workers in different positions in Rural China: a cross-sectional study

“…Job characteristics, including professional title, professional status, and working hours per week, can be tightly related to job burnout. A survey in Turkey published in 2021 found that burnout level decreased with increasing academic title, and attending physicians were the most exhausted [23]. Working over 40 hours per week was the most important risk factor for burnout in PC physicians in Oman [24].…”

A latent profile analysis of doctors’ joy in work at public hospitals

“…Doctors who were older than 45 years, on contract, and working in a secondary or tertiary hospital were more likely to have “medium joy in work” than “high joy in work.” Hospital level and doctor’s age influence patients’ choice of care, with higher-level and older doctors being preferred by patients due to more training and practical experience, as well as experience with a higher number of outpatients and inpatients. Lower levels of burnout, greater job satisfaction, and higher joy in work are experienced as age and seniority increase ( Dırvar et al, 2021 ). However, since older doctors generally have higher seniority and positions and have to undertake more clinical and managerial work in the departments, they are under a high state of mental strain.…”

Exposure to Stress and Burnout Syndrome in Healthcare Workers, Expert Workers, Professional Associates, and Associates in Social Service Institutions

“…Out of all the participants in this study, the largest number had a high school level of education. When it comes to academic titles, a study conducted in Turkey implied that the amount of burnout decreases with higher levels of academic titles [ 26 ]. The results of this study were consistent with the results of the study of workplace burnout syndrome, and the joint factors in relation to healthcare workers, where it was shown that those with the lowest education were 1.57 times more prone to emotional exhaustion in relation to those with higher education [ 27 ].…”