The effects of isocaloric substitutions of dietary polyunsaturated and saturated fat on the composition and function of plasma high density lipoproteins (HDLs) were studied in 3 normal subjects who were fed saturate-rich and polyunsaturate-rich diet programs. Compared to the saturated diets (P/S = 0.4), polyunsaturated fat diets (P/S = 4 or 2) reduced both plasma cholesterol and triglyceride levels. In 2 of the subjects, HDL cholesterol concentrations increased with polyunsaturated fat feeding; the third subject had no change in HDL cholesterol. Dietary polyunsaturated fat caused a reduction in HDL fatty acy[ content of oleate and an increase in linoleate. To determine whether the altered composition affected the removal of cell membrane cholesterol, HDL and their subfractions, HDL 2 and HDL3, which were isolated from each of the diets, were incubated with Ehrlich ascites cells in vitro. The cells were prelabeled with [3H] cholesterol, and the release of labeled cholesterol from the ceils into the medium containing the various HDL fractions was determined. HDL, irrespective of the type of dietary fat, caused a release of [3HI cholesterol from the cells into the medium. The amount of [3H] cholesterol recovered in the medium was dependent on the absolute concentration of HDL cholesterol added to the cells and was independent of the type of diet. These results indicate that HDL facilitates the removal of cholesterol from cells, but that the amount and rate of removal are independent of the changes in HDL composition that can be obtained by dietary perturbations.