“…The second assigns current climatic thresholds of active features to complex relict periglacial assemblages to deduce the most plausible palaeo-climate (Ballantyne and Harris, 1994). Such empirical interpretations, however, largely rely on flawed assumptions because suitable analogues for past periglacial environments are rare due to substantial differences in solar insolation between mid and high latitudes (Williams, 1975;French, 2017), and even if they can be found, active features present there may have developed under climatic conditions different from those which prevail at the present time (Uxa et al, 2017;Ballantyne, 2018). Climatic controls on most periglacial features are therefore poorly established, usually implying broad ranges of conditions (Washburn, 1980;Harris, 1982Harris, , 1994Karte, 1983;Wayne, 1983;Ballantyne and Harris, 1994;Huijzer and Isarin, 1997;Ballantyne, 2018), which also relates to the fact that the features partly depend on other 1 https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-2020-5 Preprint.…”