Education for Democracy, Citizenship and Social Justice: The Case of Iceland

Halldórsdóttir, Brynja Elísabeth; Jónsson, Ólafur Páll; Magnúsdóttir, Berglind Rós

doi:10.1057/978-1-137-51507-0_21

Cited by 6 publications

(2 citation statements)

References 19 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…Within the discourse of efficiency, neo-liberal economic theory has had an impact on the landscape of educational thoughts where social efficiency and the competitive state has become a superior goal of educational policy makers worldwide (Halldorsdottir Gudjonsson et al, 2016). These policy directions have directly had an impact on the development of inclusive education, for example, by influencing which focus professionals have on inclusion in their practice (Hedegaard-Soerensen & Grumloese, 2020).…”

Section: The Efficacy Discoursementioning

confidence: 99%

“…The ethical discourse argues that the benefit from inclusive schools is promoting equity and social justice and thus inclusive education can be a salvation to an unequal and unjust world (Ainscow, 2020). For example, in Iceland, the ethical discourse on inclusion is dominating and is also justified in the ideology of democracy and social justice (Biesta, 2007;Halldorsdottir Gudjonsson et al, 2016;Jónsson, 2016).…”

Section: The Ethical Discoursementioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

Inclusion in the Faroese public school: From political vision to practice in tension between general education and special needs education

Poulsen

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The research study focused on exploring the development of inclusive education in the Faroese public school from political vision to practice. The study used Situational Analysis as its theoretical and methodological framework and involved interviewing 97 actors in the Faroese school system and analysing school policy documents. The study aimed to understand how the global vision of inclusion is transferred, translated and transformed in the local environment of the Faroe Islands as a very small society. The study revealed the absence of overarching initiatives and leadership to promote inclusive education in the Faroese school system. This is partly explained through the Faroese culture and the close relationship between culture/practice and the political sector in a small society like the Faroe Islands. The research raises the question of where the impetus for initiating and motivating inclusive development processes should come from. Although the Faroe Islands is a small society with a historical dependency on Denmark, it is also part of the global world and inspired by international policies and research that affect its practice. Hence, despite being subject to the basic conditions of a small society, there are also points of similarity with the international environment. The findings reveal that the development of inclusive education in the Faroe Islands finds itself caught in the middle of cross-pressures from different and divergent global school policy trends and special features of local policy practice and local traditions and culture. The study argues that inclusive education should be an issue for an overarching school policy that applies to the entire school environment. It provides insights into pupils' perspectives, which can contribute to developing inclusive education. If pupils are listened to and heard as experts in their school lives, we can understand what it takes to achieve inclusion. In our search for effectiveness and quality of school life, pupils' perspectives can serve as a "directional indicator" for inclusion. Understanding inclusion as a situational and involvement issue means that the development of inclusion is not just about the structure and organisational and strategic measures but also about social learning processes that require involvement from multiple standpoints. In the Faroese case, this primarily means involvement from the administrative and political sectors to initiate, motivate and lead inclusive school development processes while also involving stakeholders' experiences, perspectives, views, and positions from different social worlds and arenas to discuss and negotiate how to approach and develop inclusion. The study focused on the tension between general education and special needs education problematised through a compensatory and inclusive approach. The empirical material reveals that the Faroe Islands' education system primarily has a narrow approach to translating inclusive principles into practice. Simultaneously, it also reveals that the actors view the inclusive approach as desirable but requiring significant changes in the legislation concerning political and local leadership, in structure, collaboration and with regard to understanding the concept of being professional. This research argues that developing inclusive education must be anchored in local policy and culture and may require combining compensatory and inclusive approaches to work with and handle dilemmas. In the Faroe Islands, there is an increased demand for special educational needs settings with a compensatory approach, which may hinder the transformation of inclusive principles. This is because structural reforms without working to ensure that teachers, pedagogues, and other educational and advisory staff work inclusively do not lead to the transformation of inclusive principles into practice. Developing inclusive education requires recognising and working in and with dilemmas between special needs education and general education. This study advocates a whole situational approach that has allowed me to develop and propose “situated inclusion” as a new concept in the global and local discourse on inclusive education. “Situated inclusion” addresses the four core involvement elements of community involvement, negotiating involvement, policy and administration involvement and argument involvement. This may be the direction to take to develop inclusive education in the Faroe Islands.

show abstract

Section: The Efficacy Discoursementioning

confidence: 99%

Section: The Ethical Discoursementioning

confidence: 99%

Inclusion in the Faroese public school: From political vision to practice in tension between general education and special needs education

Poulsen

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

The Irregular Formation of State Policy Documents in the Icelandic Field of Education 2013–2017

Magnúsdóttir

Jónasson

2022

Evidence and Expertise in Nordic Education Policy

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Magnúsdóttir and Jónasson explore the formation of three documents: the first white paper (WP2014) issued by Icelandic state educational authorities and two background papers (WP2017 and GP2014) co-authored by the OECD and EAIE. These papers are explored through content and bibliographic network analysis and semi-structured interviews with Ministry officials. The main results show minimal use of academic references and unsystematic use of green and white papers when forming policy. A low interconnection is between these three documents in terms of content, bibliography, and ministerial procedure. The WP2014 base their data and values mainly on OECD references. The analysis reveals a scarcity of professional resources in the Ministry, a culture of short time-frames, and loosely defined protocols in the policy making that contribute to ministerial governance and externalization.

show abstract