Editor's Comments on “Hydrogen Bonding at Aerosol Interface” by Jian-Xiang Zhang, Denise Aiello, and Pamela M. Aker, J. Phys. Chem. 1995, 99, 721.

Abstract

The observations reported in the above paper have started a vigorous debate. There was a reasonable overlap between this paper and another one published by the same authors at almost the same time in the Journal of Geophysical Research. 1 In order to save space and to avoid double publications (which is against Journal of Physical Chemistry policy), we reached an agreement with the editors of the J. Geophys. Res. to settle the debate in their journal and we publish references of the debate once it is ended. Now that the debate has ended, 2 we refer our readers who have read the above referenced paper to the debate published in refs 3-10 below. References and Notes(1) Zhang, J-X.; Aiello, D.; Aker, P. M. A spectroscopic tour through the liquid aerosol interface: Implications for atmospheric chemistry. Eversole, J. D.; Lin, H-B. Further comment on the existence of a modified hydrogen bonding ratio in laboratory-generated water droplets.