“…Whereas photosynthetic pathway—CAM or C 3 —is often portrayed as a binary trait, a variety of intermediate phenotypes ranging between full C 3 and CAM have been described. Constitutive CAM plants such as Agave are defined as species that rely on the CAM pathway constantly, regardless of even prolonged abiotic stress (Owen et al., ) (although an abundance of water can amplify C 3 carbon fixation in many constitutive CAM species) (Nobel, ). Weak CAM encompasses a variety of phenotypes, including facultative CAM (the ability to switch from C 3 to CAM under abiotic stress such as salt or drought, as found in Clusia [Borland et al., ; Lüttge, ], Mesembryanthemum [Winter and Ziegler, ; Cushman et al., ], and some Yucca species [Heyduk et al., 2016]), CAM cycling (recycling of respired CO 2 at night with daytime C 3 carbon fixation [Ting and Burk, ; Sipes and Ting, ]), and CAM idling (complete closure of stomata concomitant with recycling respired CO 2 [Sipes and Ting, ]).…”