ABSTRACr Restriction enzyme analysis of mtDNAs for the purpose of determining sequence divergence rests on the assumption that variant recognition sites differ with respect to sequence and not methylation. This assumption was tested on two mtDNAs, A and B, which are distributed throughout the laboratory rat population and which can be distinguished by a number of restriction enzymes. (5,6,12,13). Also, the high degree of this intraspecific mtDNA variation in all the species that have been studied, and particularly in Rattus rattus (ref. 11; unpublished data), suggests a rapid rate of evolution for mtDNA, and this has been proposed previously (14,15) in an interspecific comparison of mtDNAs. Thus, the restriction enzyme analysis of this rapidly evolving DNA offers an approach at high resolution to the study of the evolution of closely related species (15) and even of the population genetics within a species (refs. 10 and 11; unpublished data). The valid application of restriction endonuclease studies of mtDNA to these and associated problems rests upon a number of assumptions, two of which are relevant here. One is that the distinction between variant mtDNAs by restriction enzymes results from single base changes rather than from deletions, insertions, or rearrangements. The other is that this distinction is based on differences in nucleotide sequence rather than on differential methylation. The latter process could well play a role in the discrimination among otherwise identical DNA molecules by many bacterial restriction endonucleases, which could act in a manner analogous to their behavior in restriction-modification systems. DNA methylation is a general cellular phenomenon. In animal nuclear DNA, 5-methylcytosine is found (in CpG doublets) as the modified base (16). The detailed nature of the methylation sites of mtDNA is, however, still unsettled (17-20), although the involvement of cytosine is clear. In bacteria, relevant because of the possible prokaryotic origin of mitochondria, the methylation of guanine, adenine, and cytosine is well documented. Moreover, recent studies on the mechanism of maternal inheritance in chloroplasts (21, 22) have brought to light a methylation-restriction enzyme system and have shown that DNA methylation can affect the susceptibility of EcoRI (G-A-A-T-T-C), BamHI (G-G-A-T-C-C), and Hpa II (C-C-G-G) recognition sites to cleavage by these respective enzymes.For these reasons, it was imperative to obtain direct evidence with respect to the nature of the observed variations in nucleotide sequence. We have obtained such evidence, reported here, by cloning mtDNA in Escherichia coli and by determining the nucleotide sequences of corresponding small fragments of types A and B mtDNA, the two types found in the laboratory rat (Rattus norvegicus) population (3-8).In addition, certain coding aspects of the sequence are discussed in relation to the evolution of mtDNA. An abstract of these results containing the two sequences has been published (23). Similar conclusions have been publish...