Economic performance evaluation of process system design flexibility options under uncertainty: The case of hydrogen production plants with integrated membrane technology and CO2 capture

Abstract

A hydrogen production plant with integrated catalytic membrane reactor modules (HP-CMR) represents a new technology option with potentially enhanced environmental performance characteristics. Therefore, HP-CMR techno-economic performance in the presence of irreducible sources of uncertainty (market, regulatory) ought to be comprehensively evaluated in order to accelerate the realization of future demonstration plants. The present study introduces a systematic methodological framework allowing the economic value assessment of various flexibility options in the design and operation of an HP-CMR plant under the above uncertainty sources. The primary objective is to demonstrate the potentially value-enhancing prospects of design flexibility options that capture the inherent optionality element in managerial decisionmaking to actively respond to uncertainties as they are progressively resolved. A detailed Net Present Value (NPV)-based assessment framework is first developed within which the above sources of uncertainty are integrated through Monte Carlo techniques. Various constructional and operational flexibility options are introduced pertaining to the installation decision and operating mode choice of the carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) unit, and HP-CMR economic performance is comparatively assessed. Finally, under certain scenarios of regulatory action on CO 2 emissions, it is demonstrated that quite appealing economic performance outcomes could emerge for HP-CMR plants once design flexibility is introduced.

Techno‐economic analysis (TEA) of microbial oil production from waste resources as part of a biorefinery concept: assessment at multiple scales under uncertainty

“…A linear distribution was used for capital investment given the nature of order‐of‐magnitude estimation for capital cost. Triangular distributions are typically given to parameters where substantial uncertainty exists, particularly outside that of minimum, most likely and maximum values . Therefore, raw materials inputs were distributed triangularly.…”

“…used pedigree matrices to validate a process model for CO 2 capture with monoethanolamine . Others have applied sensitivity analysis, and Monte Carlo analysis to TEA evaluation of new technologies.…”

Supercritical CO2 cycle for coal-fired power plant based on calcium looping combustion

“…The break-even price of electricity ( ) is the key performance indicator that quantifies the economic feasibility of the CaLC-based power plant. To estimate , the value of the electricity price is changed iteratively until the NPV reaches zero [41][42][43]. The NPV (Eq.…”

Probabilistic assessment of the safety profile of the Fischer–Tropsch process with a supercritical solvent

“…Equivalently stated, process system performance (in the present paper, inherent process safety-relevant performance) evaluated at average conditions (as in traditional deterministic single point-based performance assessment models where uncertainty is conveniently ignored) does not represent a reliable measure of average performance, and therefore, quite often, leads to erroneous performance assessment outcomes/conclusions. [25,26] In probability theory, this phenomenon known as the 'flaw of averages' is mathematically represented by Jensen's inequality. Including uncertainty in process design while aiming at a more nuanced evaluation of inherent safety profile characteristics represents a true need for a proper risk assessment and the derivation of realistic insights.…”