Economic analysis of rehabilitation approaches for water distribution networks: comparative study between Egypt and Malaysia

Abstract

Purpose Sustainable water management has been a trending goal in the past decade. Non-revenue water (NRW) is one form of water loss that should be addressed to reach water sustainability. While rehabilitating water distribution networks (WDNs) is one way to decrease NRW, the process is often delayed owing to cost. Therefore, it is essential to provide decision-makers with cost-effective approaches to optimize WDN rehabilitation. This study aims to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of approaches for rehabilitating WDN from developing countries’ perspectives. Design/methodology/approach A systematic literature review was first conducted to identify different WDN rehabilitation methods and techniques to develop the questionnaire survey. This is followed by collecting questionnaire survey data in Malaysia and Egypt on the cost and effectiveness of the WDN rehabilitation methods and techniques. A total of 176 respondents were collected, 109 from Malaysia and 67 from Egypt. Then, the data were analyzed using mean score ranking with normalization technique and agreement analysis. Findings The results from the data analysis show that the cost-effective approaches are “programming,” “simulation,” “digital twin” and “supervisory control and data acquisition.” Additionally, the data from Malaysia suggest two additional cost-effective approaches: “zoning network” and “genetic algorithm.” Originality/value To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this paper presents one of the first studies that laterally compares the cost-effectiveness of existing and potential WDN rehabilitation approaches between different countries. There is yet a study that compared these WDN rehabilitation approaches. This comparison which is developed depending on the systematic review could be a reference for future studies or surveys which could be done on different countries in the future. The main findings of this paper can be a useful reference for decision-makers, especially those from middle-income countries, when looking into approaches for WDN rehabilitation. A better WDN rehabilitation supports NRW reduction, moving towards sustainable water management.

Effect of Mega Railway Projects on Small and Medium Construction Companies: Impact and Problems

“…Phase six involves the final analysis and preparation of the report when the authors set fully developed themes. Within the domain of construction management research, resaerch papers frequently apply the themaitc analysis on analyzing qualitaive data such as literature and interviews [26,27]. This method serves as a pivotal tool for exploring various dimensions of construction management.…”

Performance Indicators for Assessing Environmental Management Plan Implementation in Water Projects

“…The respondents were requested to rank the performance indicators using a five-point Likert scale, with one being not important and five being very important. The Likert scale was chosen for its precision, and it is commonly used in construction management research [36]. Finally, the respondents were provided with space at the end of the survey to add and rank any additional performance indicators that they deemed necessary.…”

Critical Success Factors for Concrete Recycling in Construction Projects

“…To acquire the normalized values, the mean scores for each of the 12 success variables had to be determined using a similar technique. Only variables with a normalized value of 0.50 or higher were critical [29,39]. Other studies, such as the cost-effectiveness of optimization solutions for water distribution network rehabilitation, used the same data analysis technique [39].…”

“…Only variables with a normalized value of 0.50 or higher were critical [29,39]. Other studies, such as the cost-effectiveness of optimization solutions for water distribution network rehabilitation, used the same data analysis technique [39].…”