Ecological specialisation, rather than the island effect, explains morphological diversification in an ancient radiation of geckos

Abstract

Island colonists are often assumed to experience higher levels of phenotypic diversification than their continental sister taxa. However, empirical evidence shows that exceptions to the familiar "island rule" do exist. In this study, we tested this rule using a nearly complete sampled mainland-island system, the genus Pristurus, a group of sphaerodactylid geckos mainly distributed across continental Arabia and Africa and the Socotra Archipelago. We used a recently published phylogeny and an extensive dataset of morphological measures to explore whether island and mainland taxa share the same morphospace or if they present different dynamics of phenotypic evolution. Moreover, we used habitat data to examine if ecological specialization is correlated with morphological change, reconstructing the ancestral habitat states across the phylogeny to compare the level of phenotypic disparity and trait evolution between habitats. We found that insular species do not present higher levels or rates of morphological diversification than continental groups. Instead, habitat specialization provides insight into the evolution of body size and shape in Pristurus. In particular, the adaptation to exploit ground habitats seems to have been the main driver of morphological change, producing the highest levels of disparity and evolutionary rates. Additionally, arboreal species show very constrained body size and head proportions, suggesting morphological convergence driven by habitat specialization. Our results reveal a determinant role of ecological mechanisms in morphological evolution and corroborate the complexity of ecomorphological dynamics in mainland-island systems.

A new species of feather-tailed leaf-toed gecko, Kolekanos Heinicke, Daza, Greenbaum, Jackman, Bauer, 2014 (Squamata, Gekkonidae) from the poorly explored savannah of western Angola

“…In addition, both species present a distinctive tail ornamentation that can be used as a clear morphological diagnostic feature between them. These findings seem to be consistent with the idea that habitat diversity leads to species and morphological diversification ( Losos and Parent 2009 ; Tejero-Cicuéndez et al 2021 ).…”