Ecological Risk Assessment Framework for Low‐Altitude Aircraft Overflights: I. Planning the Analysis and Estimating Exposure

Abstract

An ecological risk assessment framework for low-altitude aircraft overflights was developed, with special emphasis on military applications. The problem formulation and exposure analysis phases are presented in this article; an analysis of effects and risk characterization is presented in a companion article. The intent of this article is threefold: (1) to illustrate the development of a generic framework for the ecological risk assessment of an activity, (2) to show how the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's ecological risk assessment paradigm can be applied to an activity other than the release of a chemical, and (3) to provide guidance for the assessment of ecological risks from low-altitude aircraft overflights. The key stressor for low-altitude aircraft overflights is usually sound, although visual and physical (collision) stressors may also be significant. Susceptible and regulated wildlife populations are the major assessment endpoint entities, although plant communities may be impacted by takeoffs and landings. The exposure analysis utilizes measurements of wildlife locations, measurements of sound levels at the wildlife locations, measurements of slant distances from aircraft to wildlife, models that extrapolate sound from the source aircraft to the ground, and bird-strike probability models. Some of the challenges to conducting a risk assessment for aircraft overflights include prioritizing potential stressors and endpoints, choosing exposure metrics that relate to wildlife responses, obtaining good estimates of sound or distance, and estimating wildlife locations.

Integrating Multiple Pressures at Different Spatial and Temporal Scales: A Concept for Relative Ecological Risk Assessment in the European Marine Environment

“…In landscape ecology, the exposure of two goods is dependent on their spatial distributions (Efroymson et al 2001;Wiegers et al 1998). Thus, the likelihood E of being impacted by pressure k is determined as overlap O…”

Military Ecological Risk Assessment Framework (MERAF) for Assessment of Risks of Military Training and Testing to Natural Resources

“…MERAF subframeworks are also planned for a set of high priority activities, and an activity-specific subframework has been completed for military aircraft overflights (Efroymson et al 2000, Efroymson et al 2001a, Efroymson and Suter 2001. Activityspecific frameworks of MERAF are generic, in the sense that they will explain how to assess the risks from those activities at any place or time.…”

Wildlife Strike Risk Assessment in Several Italian Airports: Lessons from BRI and a New Methodology Implementation

“…The major problem with these approaches is that they may not reflect the characteristics of each individual airport, making comparisons between airports difficult. To render things even more complicated it often happens that the wildlife strike data available are incomplete because records from pilots may lack species information or carcasses may be lost [18]. Thus, there is a general need for a standardized method that is easy to apply and statistically robust.…”