Ecological Change and the Politics of African Land Use

Abstract

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.. African Studies Association is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to African Studies Review. INTRODUCTIONThis essay explores ground common to ecology and politics.1 It addresses the question to what extent and in what ways are ecological ideas political ideas. The discussion, divided into five man sections, endeavors to steer a course between the pitfalls of environmental determinism on the one hand and economic reductionism on the other.The first section deals with the link between population processes and land use. Explanations stressing population increase as the driving force behind agricultural change are contrasted with arguments in which demographic fluctuations are treated as responses to economic imperatives. An example of the second kind of approach is Meillassoux's attempt to reconstruct the demographic dynamic of a precapitalist, lineage, mode of production. This is but one of a number of attempts to construct models of "natural economy" as starting points for discussions of the penetration of African agriculture by capitalism. Against the assumptions on which such models are based it is argued here, and in later sections of the paper, that the demographic and ecological processes subsumed under the category "natural economy" (or alternatively, "precapitalist subsistence production") are more plausibly viewed as products of capitalism and colonialism. An example from southern Nigeria in the early colonial period is used to suggest that the kind of evidence on which Meillassoux's reconstruction is based is a complex ideological by-product of factional politics in an economy dominated by merchant capital.The second section of the paper focuses on the topic of the ecology of disease in Africa. Special attention is paid to John Ford's (1971) work on the ecology of trypanosomiasis. Critical of colonial scientific orthodoxy, and of colonialism itself (properly treated as a factor in the spread of sleeping sickness in Africa in the twentieth century), Ford's book has received some attention from Africanists in the social sciences and humanities. It is probably fair to say, however, that the originality of the book's ecological argument has yet to have its full impact on such readers. This is the justification for substantial summary of one of Ford's case studies. The significance of this case study is that is illustrates the ecological complexity characteristic of trypanosomiasis, and of a number of other African epidemic diseases, and the importance of local knowledge and initiative in African Studies Review, vol. 26, no. 2, June, 1983. 1 This content downloaded from 62.122.78.57 on Mon, 9 Jun 2014 19:30:54 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and...

Communal land use and the ‘tragedy of the commons’: Some problems and development perspectives with specific reference to semi‐arid regions of southern Africa

“…Furthermore, the contemporary situation may not reflect traditional management practices, especially where the introduction of outside controls and constraints has caused these to lapse (Gulbrandsen, 1980). Similarly, although there has been relatively little research to date, it has been shown that traditional farmers have detailed (and often sophisticated) local knowledge concerning the geographical and climatic environment, plants and animals (Chambers & Howes, 1979;Brokensha, 1980;Chambers, 1983;Richards, 1983;Bodley, 1985).…”

The history and future of agricultural experiments

“…Labour employed in cash crops implied that farmers neglected rice cultivation. 1 After the forced labour regime had been abolished, Holle's on-farm experiments were to re-educate rice farmers in taking better care of their rice fields.…”

“…Based on anthropological fieldwork among rice farmers in Sierra Leone, Richards in particular emphasized how farmers deal with the agro-ecological conditions as a performance. In farming practice, experimentation is a crucial act to improve farming results in subsequent seasons [1,2]. At first glance, the experiments by farmers look completely different from the scientific experiments performed on controlled experimental plots, often in climate-conditioned greenhouses.…”

Sleeping Sickness in the History of Northeast Congo (Zaire)

“…At times of epidemics. the true nature of social relations is often clearly revealed when different sectors of a society are brought into conflict (Morris 1976;M usambachime 1981;Briggs 1961;Richards 1983). The subject of disease in the historiography of Africa had been generally ignored until 1978.…”