Echo chamber effects on short video platforms

Abstract

In recent years, short videos have become an increasingly vital source of information. To compete for users’ attention, short video platforms have been overusing algorithmic technology, making the group polarization intensify, which is likely to push users into the homogeneous “echo chamber”. However, echo chambers can contribute to the spread of misleading information, false news, or rumors, which have negative social impacts. Therefore, it is necessary to explore echo chamber effects in short video platforms. Moreover, the communication paradigms between users and feed algorithms greatly vary across short video platforms. This paper investigated echo chamber effects of three popular short video platforms (Douyin, TikTok, and Bilibili) using social network analysis and explored how user features influenced the generation of echo chambers. We quantified echo chamber effects through two primary ingredients: selective exposure and homophily, in both platform and topic dimensions. Our analyses indicate that the gathering of users into homogeneous groups dominates online interactions on Douyin and Bilibili. We performed performance comparison of echo chamber effects and found that echo chamber members tend to display themselves to attract the attention of their peers and that cultural differences can prevent the development of echo chambers. Our findings are of great value in designing targeted management strategies to prevent the spread of misleading information, false news, or rumors.

Personality traits and their influence on Echo chamber formation in social media: a comparative study of Twitter and Weibo

“…Consequently, we have developed a method to determine whether selective exposure occurs within echo chambers. In other words, by analyzing the polarity of opinions in the comment texts of echo chamber participants, we can ascertain the extent of selective exposure among users on social media ( Gao et al, 2023a , b ).…”

Analyzing Radical Visuals at Scale

“…The 'For You' page (FYP) on TikTok algorithmically curates a selection of videos, prioritizing new and trending content over users' existing connections (Weimann & Masri, 2021;Zeng & Kaye, 2022), thereby enhancing the potential for any video to go viral and making the platform a hub for (political) mobilization (Zulli & Zulli, 2022). However, TikTok's algorithm is known for having a strong locking mechanism through which content that has been previously viewed or engaged with is prospectively prioritized (Gao et al, 2023). This tendency is also observed by Grandinetti and Bruinsma (2022), who find that TikTok's algorithm quickly adapts to polarized political content.…”

Research on the Dynamical Behavior of Public Opinion Triggered by Rumor Based on a Nonlinear Oscillator Model

“…"Zhiweidata" is a famous comprehensive data analysis platform of online events in China and was widely used in research [23]. "Zhiweidata" can offer data of spread trends for each case.…”