Easy does it: an innovative view on developing career identity and self-direction

Abstract

Purpose A generally held belief in the field of career development is that career attitudes and abilities, including identity and self-direction, can and should be developed in school programmes with a cognitive focus. The purpose of this paper is twofold: first, to question this belief, and second, to provide a new perspective on career development that may inspire innovations for career science, and guidance during the lifespan. Design/methodology/approach Specific questions are formulated and answered on the basis of sources mainly stemming from neurosciences and different sub-disciplines of psychology. On the basis of a systems theory, a new approach is proposed. Findings Current approaches in career guidance are at odds with findings and insights from developmental sciences and brain research. Several risks of current approaches are described. One risk is identity foreclosure. Another risk involves the development of ineffective ways of thinking and decision making. A control theory that stems from cybernetics is proposed to offer an alternative view on career development. Research limitations/implications One implication for research is that long-term longitudinal approaches are required to fully clarify the development of self-direction and identity. Furthermore, the building and testing of models of career development based on dynamic systems theories is recommended. Practical implications The main implication for career practices and policies is that self-direction and identity are no realistic aims for most students. Instead, it is recommended to relieve the pressure associated with career choices for young people, and to give more time, room, stimulation and guidance for exploration and reconsideration, for adults as well. Guidance should consist of offering sufficiently varied work experiences, and counselling when individuals experience conflicts that impede direction finding. Not too much emphasis should be put on reflection and rational thinking. Acceptance and commitment therapy is recommended as an approach offering many useful insights and instruments that may inspire career professionals. Originality/value This paper questions a mainstream approach and offers an original point of view.

What shapes the pathway of becoming an elderly care worker? Young Workers’ perspective

“…Overall, the research not only confirms the presence of various factors and circumstances that influence the choice of care work among young workers, as discussed in caregiver development theories but also highlights the significant role of self-identity exploration in this process. The conducted research supports the notion that there are strong connections between career choice and one's sense of self and identity (see : Luken, 2020). In terms of self-identity, our study participants exhibited a typical motivation towards public service, as they associated their choice of care work with intrinsic rewards such as a sense of accomplishment, self-worth, and satisfaction derived from helping others.…”

“…Social identity ideas are also important in explaining career decisions, as they are often closely tied to one's sense of self and identity (Berger, 1963). Additionally, there are strong links between career choice and self/ identity, as evidenced by studies conducted by Gagne (2014), Kanter Moss (1977, Maree (2019), Ryan andDeci (2018), andLuken (2020). Furthermore, the concept of public services motivation is relevant in the explanation of career choice, as it emphasises the significance of intrinsic rewards (such as a sense of accomplishment and self-worth in choosing helping professions (Bozeman & Su, 2015;Houston, 2000;Perry & Hondeghem, 2008)).…”

Accessibility and Usability of Social Network for Career Guidiance Among Secondary School Student of Ilorin Metropolis

“…In secondary school vocational education, career identity is viewed as a network of meaning where individuals consciously connect their motives, interests, and capabilities to suitable professional roles (Luken, 2020). Luken suggests that a strong career identity empowers students to navigate their careers independently, fostering more self-direction in achieving their desired career paths.…”

The Effective Guidance Path of High-Quality Employment for College Students in the Internet Perspective

“…Furthermore, universities can help improve students' employability and flexibility to compete in society and for jobs by teaching generic skills for careers. Literature [22] presents a viewpoint, i.e., a long-term longitudinal approach to the development of self-direction and identity, according to which the construction and testing of a model of career development based on dynamic systems theory is proposed. It is advised that young people are provided with time and space to explore, with assistance from counselors when needed.…”