Earnings shocks and tax-motivated income-shifting: Evidence from European multinationals

Abstract

This paper presents a new approach to estimating the existence and magnitude of taxmotivated income shifting within multinational corporations. Existing studies of income shifting use changes in corporate tax rates as a source of identification. In contrast, this paper exploits exogenous earnings shocks at the parent firm and investigates how these shocks propagate across low-tax and high-tax multinational subsidiaries. This approach is implemented using a large panel of European multinational affiliates over the period [1995][1996][1997][1998][1999][2000][2001][2002][2003][2004][2005]. The central result is that parents' positive earnings shocks are associated with a significantly positive increase in pretax profits at low-tax affiliates, relative to the effect on the pretax profits of high-tax affiliates. The result is robust to controlling for various other differences between low-tax and high-tax affiliates and for country-pair-year fixed effects. Additional tests suggest that the estimated effect is attributable primarily to the strategic use of debt across affiliates. The magnitude of income shifting estimated using this approach is substantial, but somewhat smaller than that found in the previous literature. Acknowledgments:We thank participants at the

Large and Influential: Firm Size and Governments’ Corporate Tax Rate Choice?

“…Next to controlling for observed and unobserved heterogeneity, we moreover pursue an instrumental variable strategy to hedge against results that are driven by potential firm size responses to changes in jurisdictions' tax policies -where the direction of the OLS-bias is a priori unclear: low business taxes may attract firms of above average size (biasing the α 2 -estimate upwards in absolute terms) but may simultaneously also foster entrepreneurship and the foundation of new (and, in consequence, small) companies (biasing the α 2 -estimate downwards in absolute terms). Our instrumental variable strategy will exploit industry-level-shocks as an exogenous driver of individual firm size (see Bertrand et al (2002) and Dharmapala and Riedel (2013) for similar approaches) and, in consequence, of localities' aggregate firm size structures. 19…”

Measuring misalignment: The location of US multinationals’ economic activity versus the location of their profits

“…A number of empirical studies use corporate balance sheet data for OECD countries, finding support for the hypothesis that international profit shifting in response to tax differentials is statistically and economically significant. Dharmapala (2014) reviews the literature on how the reported income changes with respect to tax rates differs across countries, represented by Hines and Rice (1994), Huizinga and Laeven (2008) and Dharmapala and Riedel (2013). Grubert and Mutti (1991), as well as Clausing (2003Clausing ( , 2016, provide evidence for the US; Huizinga and Laeven (2008), Weichenrieder (2009) and Loretz and Mokkas (2015) present more recent evidence for European multinationals.…”

Taxes and the location of targets

“…SeeDharmapala (2014) for a recent review of the vast literature on the effect of taxes on profit shifting. For empirical evidence on this topic, seeEgger et al (2010) andEgger et al (2014), who use German data Dharmapala and Riedel (2013),. who trace the effect of positive earnings shocks at the parent level on the profit of low-tax subsidiaries.…”