Early life conditions influence fledging success and subsequent local recruitment rates in a declining migratory songbird, the Whinchat Saxicola rubetra

Abstract

Life history traits and environmental conditions influence reproductive success in animals, and consequences of these can influence subsequent survival and recruitment into breeding populations. Understanding influences on demographic rates is required to determine the causes of decline. Migratory species experience spatially and temporally variable conditions across their annual cycle, making identifying where the factors influencing demographic rates operate challenging. Here, we use the Whinchat Saxicola rubetra as a model declining long-distance migrant bird. We analyse 10 years of data from 247 nesting attempts and 2519 post-fledging observations of 1193 uniquely marked nestlings to examine the influence of life history traits, habitat characteristics and weather on survival of young from the nestling stage to local recruitment into the natal population. We detected potential silver spoon effects where conditions during the breeding stage influence subsequent apparent local recruitment rates, with higher recruitment for fledglings from larger broods, and recruitment rate negatively related to rainfall that chicks experienced in-nest. Additionally, extreme temperatures experienced pre-and post-fledging increased fledging success and recruitment rate. However, we could not determine whether this was driven by temperature influencing mortality during the post-fledging period or later in the annual cycle.Brood size declined with hatching date. In-nest survival increased with brood size and was highest at local temperature extremes. Furthermore, nest survival was highest at nests surrounded with 40%-60% vegetation cover of Bracken Pteridium aquilinum within 50 m of the nest. Our results show that breeding phenology and environmental factors may influence fledging success and recruitment in songbird populations, with conditions experienced during the nestling stage influencing local recruitment rates in Whinchats (i.e. silver spoon effect). Recruitment rates are key drivers of songbird population dynamics. Our results help identify some of the likely breeding season mechanisms that could be important population drivers.

Context-specific “silver-spoon” effects of wetlands, climate, and temperature on lifetime fitness in a short-lived temperate-breeding migratory songbird

“…Early life conditions can have both short-and long-term consequences for fitness-related traits of offspring (Lindström, 1999). Short-term effects of early life conditions on offspring have been well characterized, and shown to affect offspring quality (e.g., pre-fledging body mass or condition) and survival, or probability of recruitment to the breeding population (Ancona et al, 2018;Halliwell et al, 2023). However, short-term effects of early life conditions on offspring are not always detected on fitness components over the long term, i.e., after local recruitment to the breeding population (Nevoux et al, 2010;Cam and Aubry, 2011;Mumme et al, 2015).…”

DataSheet_1.pdf

“…Early life conditions can have both short-and long-term consequences for fitness-related traits of offspring (Lindström, 1999). Short-term effects of early life conditions on offspring have been well characterized, and shown to affect offspring quality (e.g., pre-fledging body mass or condition) and survival, or probability of recruitment to the breeding population (Ancona et al, 2018;Halliwell et al, 2023). However, short-term effects of early life conditions on offspring are not always detected on fitness components over the long term, i.e., after local recruitment to the breeding population (Nevoux et al, 2010;Cam and Aubry, 2011;Mumme et al, 2015).…”