E-government services evaluation from citizen satisfaction perspective

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to analyze and evaluate the current status of e-government services in Afghanistan. To identify the evaluation criteria based on citizen satisfaction from e-government services, the proposed government-to-citizen (G2C) evaluation model is considered in the context of Afghanistan. Design/methodology/approach A conceptual G2C evaluation model and e-government evaluation model are proposed. The criteria used for the G2C evaluation model is based on the demand and supply side, which have an immense effect on citizen satisfaction. The mixed research method (quantitative and qualitative) is used, and quantitative data analysis results are supported through qualitative data analysis. Findings The findings reveal that citizen satisfaction from e-government services in Afghanistan are affected by services availability on multiple channels, citizen-centric features, paralingual support, process performance, skills divide, awareness, information security and transaction security. Research limitations/implications Yet to be addressed, three criteria deemed as significant factors are recommended to be included in the model, namely, government readiness, system quality (usability, service quality and information quality) for supply side and social divide for demand side. These three criteria can help in proposing a successful G2C evaluation model. Additionally, the quantitative data used in this study were collected through paper-based questionnaires. Data collection through Internet can help to get responses from various parts of the country for future evaluation of G2C services. Practical implications The key findings of this study are vitally important for e-government strategies and policy makers to design and disseminate appropriate e-government services to Afghan citizens. The proposed evaluation model can also be used as a guideline for e-government development in Afghanistan. Originality/value A conceptual model for e-government services evaluation approach is proposed based on literature review. The proposed G2C evaluation model identifies and validates key factors and criteria in the context of Afghanistan.

Improving qualities of e‐government services in Rwanda: A service provider perspective

“…These include (1) citizens' expectations including service functionality (performance, service, and interoperability) and user motivation (trust, ease of use, perceived benefits, and internet skills) and (2) facilitating conditions that encompass an enabling infrastructure (internet penetration, accessibility, and multichannel) and government preparedness (coordination, commitment from top management, awareness, funding, government process change toward a citizen-centric mode, and legal issues). In Afghanistan, Anwer, Esichaikul, Rehman, and Anjum (2016) find that service availability on multiple channels, citizen-centric features, paralingual support, process performance, user skills, awareness, information security, and transaction security influence e-government citizen satisfaction.…”

Municipal Awareness as an Integral Part for Enhancing Citizen Satisfaction of Malaysian Municipal Councils, Batu Pahat

“…It was evident that enlightenment of municipal residents, it's imperatives to accommodate service users through informing them the issues that municipal councils intend to address in the given financial year. Peoples are contented mostly with the performance of their municipal councils, most especially in the aspects of public toilet provisioning as evident by [15]. The significance of municipal awareness was highlighted to ascertain the improvement of citizen satisfaction in the municipal councils.…”

“…This general and national measurement gadget for customer satisfaction and customer loyalty is called the Swedish Customer Satisfaction Barometer (SCSB). Satisfaction of municipal services is one of the major evaluation of LAs service delivery performance [15]. LAs performance must commiserate with citizen satisfaction of municipal services provisioned by local council, satisfaction of citizenry should be main target of municipal council officials.…”

Evidence of Municipal Awareness as a Construct for Enhancing Citizen Satisfaction in Municipal Council of Malaysia

“…This general and national measurement gadget for customer satisfaction and customer loyalty is called the Swedish Customer Satisfaction Barometer (SCSB). Satisfaction of municipal services is one of the major evaluation of Municipal councils service delivery performance [14]. Municipal councils performance must commiserate with citizen satisfaction of municipal services provisioned by local council, satisfaction of citizenry should be main target of local government officials.…”