Dying at home – is it better: A narrative appraisal of the state of the science

Abstract

Background: Achieving home care and home death is increasingly used as an outcome measure of palliative care services. Aim: To appraise the state of the science on dying at home. Methods: Appraisal and narrative review developed from a plenary presentation at the European Association for Palliative Care (EAPC) 2012 meeting examining the research on variations and trends in place of death, factors associated with dying in the preferred place, presenting evidence on outcomes for those dying at home and suggesting future research questions. Results: Meeting patients' preferences and creating home-like environments has been a major concern for hospice and palliative care since its inception. During the 20 th century, in many countries, hospital deaths increased and home deaths reduced. Despite the fact that this trend has been halted or reversed in some countries (notably the United States, Canada and, more recently, the United Kingdom) in the last 5-20 years, a home death is still a distant reality for the majority, even though evidence shows it is the most commonly preferred place to die. Epidemiological studies identified factors associated with home death, including affluence, patients' preferences, provision of home care and extended family support. Evidence about the benefits of home care is conflicting, but recent data suggest that holistic well-being may be greater at home. Implications: We call for further analyses of variations in place of care and place of death and robust studies on how patients and families formulate and change preferences over time. Regular monitoring of outcomes, quality and costs of palliative home care is urged.

Impact of the Macmillan specialist Care at Home service: a mixed methods evaluation across six sites

“…The vast majority of community based palliative care is still related to symptom control, additional or enhanced support, coordinating care and end of life care [66,67]. Moreover, there is little research that has formally evaluated or researched the impact of specialised interventions into home care.…”

Temporal Association between Home Nursing and Hospital Costs at End of Life in Three Provinces

“…This group of patients is distinct, given that they received no palliative nursing services that might prevent subsequent hospitalizations. We hypothesize that patients receiving no nursing were less medically complex or had sufficient caregiver support, both factors being associated with less hospitalization 27 . They could also have been in a quiescent period in the progression of their illness or in a residential hospice (although, because of a shortage of facilities, only 2% of all deaths in Ontario occur in a hospice).…”

The Right Place at the Right Time: Medical Oncology Outpatients' Perceptions of Location of End-of-Life Care

“…1 Where people are cared for at EOL is an important public health issue. EOL care delivered in hospitals is often resource-intensive, costly, and does not consistently meet patients' needs.…”